More Discussions for this daf
1. tense/order 2. Toil-Free in Egypt 3. TOSFOS DH ELA d'Ka'i
4. Eisanim 5. The Twelfth Principle of the Rambam 6. Mazalos
7. Mazalos 8. Did Man really want to be Created? 9. Creation in Nisan or Tishrei
10. Parents vs. Mountains 11. Shaving on Rosh Hashanah 12. Machlokes R"I and R"E
13. Month the world was created in 14. Point by Point Outlines and Review questions - Correction 15. In What Month Was the World Created?
16. אלא דקאי בחג ואמר ליה 17. מחלוקת ר"י ור"א בענין בריאת העולם
DAF DISCUSSIONS - ROSH HASHANAH 11

Akiva Maresky asks:

Shalom, I had a problem how your site explains the gemara on the top of 11A.

R'Eliezer uses for his reasoning why the world was created in Tishrei - and quotes from the pasuk "etz pri" - when the trees are full of fruit.

R'Yehoshua reasons that the world was created in Nisan and quotes from the pasuk "etz oseh pri" - when the trees are forming fruit.

Then the gemara asks, veidach (the other one) how does he use "etz oseh pri"? This should be R'Eliezer, since before he only quoted "etz pri", yet your site (http://www.dafyomi.co.il/rhashanah/points/rh-ps-011.htm and also the question/answer review) writes that the v'idach here is R'Yehoshua.

And I had the same problem for the other veidach - how he explains "etz pri" - on your site it says that this is R'Eliezer, yet R'Eliezer already quoted that in his original reasoning! I would think that this is supposed to be R'Yehoshua.

Akiva Maresky, Otniel Canada

The Kollel replies:

Thank you for your attention. We will make the correction.

Kollel Iyun Hadaf