More Discussions for this daf
1. tense/order 2. Toil-Free in Egypt 3. TOSFOS DH ELA d'Ka'i
4. Eisanim 5. The Twelfth Principle of the Rambam 6. Mazalos
7. Mazalos 8. Did Man really want to be Created? 9. Creation in Nisan or Tishrei
10. Parents vs. Mountains 11. Shaving on Rosh Hashanah 12. Machlokes R"I and R"E
13. Month the world was created in 14. Point by Point Outlines and Review questions - Correction 15. In What Month Was the World Created?
16. אלא דקאי בחג ואמר ליה 17. מחלוקת ר"י ור"א בענין בריאת העולם
DAF DISCUSSIONS - ROSH HASHANAH 11

Yaacob Bendayan asks:

TOSFOS DH ELA D'KA'I B'CHAG V'KA'AMAR LAH B'NISAN

Check 1. Source #1, 2. Source #2 and (b) Clarification.

Why Tosfos says that lav davka in succos?, if source#2 says that Avraham Avinu was circumcised on Yom ha'Kipurim and source#1 says on the third day after his Milah the angels came to him. It is davka succos: kipur plus 3 days is actually succos

Yaacob Bendayan, Caracas, Venezuela

The Kollel replies:

Yom Kippur is on the 10th of Tishrei and Sukos is on 15 Tishrei, so if the angels came to Avraham Avinu on the third day after the Milah that means they came on 13 Tishrei, which is why Tosfos says that Sukos is Lav Davka, because it was really two days before Sukos.

Kol Tuv,

Dovid Bloom

(We apologize for the delay in responding!)