More Discussions for this daf
1. Ki Setze Eish 2. Comments On The Beginning Of The Maseches 3. Shor that Caused Damages
4. Wording of the Mishnah 5. Bulls are domestic? 6. Av and Toldah
7. Hev'er or Esh? 8. Mechayev 9. "Hen" in numbered list
10. Does a person have Mazal? 11. Difference between Avos and Toldos 12. הערות על תחילת המסכת
13. רש״י ד״ה בעיטה 14. אב ותולדה 15. הבער או אש
16. מחייב 17. השור והבור
DAF DISCUSSIONS - BAVA KAMA 2

yaakov fisch asked:

In bava kamma 2b rashi says that person has daas in order to survive but in shabbos 53b he says that a person has an angel guarding over him .is this a contradiction

yaakov fisch, jacksonville,florida

The Kollel replies:

Dear Yaacov,

Hello there and thanks for your question. Rashi in Bava Kama actually suggests two explanations. One is that he has Da'as as you mentioned, and the second explanation which can fit with his explanation in Shabbos. Perhaps this is what the Gilyon ha'Shas meant when he referred to Rashi's explanation in Shabbos. As a rule, throughout Shas Rashi does not always give identical explanations to similar terms or even sugyos. It could be that Rashi had two explanations and in Shabbos chose the one that fit best there, and in Bava Kama chose the one that fit best here.

Kol tuv

Y. Landy