(R. Yochanan): [The Shi'urim of] a Ma'ah Kesef and two Kesef are mid'Oraisa.

(R. Yosi - Beraisa, in front of R. Yochanan): [Mid'Oraisa, the Re'iyah is any amount. Chachamim said a Ma'ah Kesef and two Kesef.

Question (R. Yochanan): Do we find like this [that the Torah did not give a Shi'ur, and Chachamim fixed a Shi'ur]?!

Objection (R. Yonah): Did not Chachamim give all Shi'urim - k'Zayis of a Mes, k'Zayis of a Neveilah, and k'Adashah of a Sheretz?!

Correction: Rather, R. Yochanan challenged R. Hoshayah's teaching (R. SHLOMO SIRILIYO, Pe'ah 1:1);

(R. Hoshayah - Beraisa): "[V']Lo Yir'u Panai Reikam'' - any amount. Chachamim said a Ma'ah Kesef and two Kesef.

Question (R. Yochanan): He brings support from the verse [that any amount] is Torah law [the Torah did not leave the Shi'ur for Chachamim to fix. If so, how could] Chachamim say a Ma'ah Kesef and two Kesef?! (GRA Pe'ah 1:1, Kesav Yad 2.)

(R. Yosi bei R. Bun): R. Yochanan says like he taught elsewhere, and R. Hoshayah says like he taught elsewhere;

R. Yochanan says like he taught elsewhere, that all Shi'urim are a tradition from Moshe from Sinai;

[And here] he said that Ma'ah Kesef and two Kesef are mid'Oraisa.

R. Hoshayah says like he taught elsewhere. R. Hoshayah said that one who eats an Isur [Kares] nowadays [after the Churban] must record the amount he ate, lest another Beis Din will change the Shi'urim, and he will know what Shi'ur he ate. (If he merely records "I am liable for eating Chelev'', he may bring a Korban later, even if they increased the Shi'ur, and really, he is exempt!)

[And here] he said that [mid'Oraisa,] Re'iyah is any amount. Chachamim said a Ma'ah Kesef and two Kesef.

R. Yochanan retracted from this [and accepted R. Hoshayah's opinion].

(R. Yonah and R. Yonason): He did not retract. [We know this] from the following;

The Gemara does not explain how we know that he did not retract also from the latter. Perhaps we assume so because he argues with Reish Lakish, who learned with him towards the end of R. Yochanan's life.

(R. La citing R. Imi): Chizkiyah and R. Yochanan argued. Chizkiyah said that one may divide his obligation (the two Kesef that he must spend for Chagigah) onto two animals. R. Yochanan said that one may not divide his obligation onto two animals. Rather, he must have in his hand two Kesef for each one. (Since R. Yochanan holds that the Shi'ur is mid'Oraisa, it must be fulfilled through one animal.)

(Reish Lakish citing Chizkiyah): One may be Tofel animals to an animal (he brings one Chagigah from Chulin, and additional Chagigos from Kesef Ma'aser), but one may not be Tofel Ma'os to a Ma'ah (buy one animal with the required Shi'ur from Chulin coins, and the rest of the price from Kesef Ma'aser);

(R. Yochanan): One may be Tofel Ma'os to a Ma'ah, but one may not be Tofel animals to an animal.

Question: What is the law if there were 10 animals in front of him, and he offered five of them on Yom Tov Rishon. Do the rest override Yom Tov Acharon [are they considered Chagigah, which overrides Yom Tov]?

Answer (R. Krispi): R. Yochanan and Reish Lakish argue about this. One of them said that they override, and the other said that they do not override, and we do not know who said who said this.

Clarification (R. Ze'irah): We can explain [who said what] from their words [above]. R. Yochanan said that one may be Tofel Ma'os to a Ma'ah, but one may be Tofel animals to an animal. He said that [all have Kedushas Chagigah, so] the last five] override. Reish Lakish said that one may be Tofel animals to an animal, but one may be Tofel Ma'os to a Ma'ah. He said that [the others are like Nedarim and Nedavos, so] they do not override.

(Shimon bar Ba citing R. Yochanan): One may always add and they override Yom Tov, until he says "I do not want to add.'' (If he adds afterwards, it is like Nedarim and Nedavos, which do not override.)

(Mishnah): Olos during the Mo'ed come from Chulin, and Shelamim [may come even] from Ma'aser;

On the first Yom Tov of the Chag, Beis Shamai say that [Shelamim] come from Chulin, and Beis Hillel say, from Ma'aser.

(Gemara - R. Tanchum bar Ilai citing R. Yosi bei R. Chaninah): So Beis Shamai answer Beis Hillel - something that is obligatory to bring it, does it come from Ma'aser?!

Beis Hillel: During Chol [ha'Mo'ed], does he not bring one of Chulin, and he is Tofel (joins it) to Ma'aser? Here (the first day) he brings one of Chulin, and he is Tofel to Ma'aser!

Question: What is the source that he is Tofel to Ma'aser?

Answer #1 (R. Yosi ben Chaninah): It says here [regarding Shavu'os] "Misas'', and it says there "Ki Lo Suchal Seiso.'' Just like Seiso there is Ma'aser, also here it is Ma'aser.

Answer #2 (R. Lazar): It says here [about Yom Tov] Simchah, and it says there (about Ma'aser Sheni) Simchah. Just like Simchah there is Ma'aser, also here it is Ma'aser.

Question: [If so] he should [be able to] bring all of them from Ma'aser!

Answer (Ula bar Yishmael): It says here [regarding Shavu'os] "Misas'', and it says there "va'Terev Mas'as Binyamin.'' Just like Mas'as there, one is primary and the rest is secondary, also Mas'as here, one is primary and the rest is secondary.

Question (R. Yosi bei R. Bun): Shelamim of Nedavah are like Shelamim of Chagigah. [According to Reish Lakish, who says that one may be Tofel animals, but not coins], why do we need verses? (The extra Chagigos are like Shelamim, which may come from Ma'aser! We explained this like HA'GAON RAV C. KANIEVSKY, SHLITA.)

Answer: [The verses] teach that [they are called Chagigos,] which override (may be offered) on Yom Tov.