1)

FOR WHICH PITS IS ONE LIABLE? (Yerushalmi Perek 5 Halachah 6 Daf 24b)

מתני' החופר בור ברשות הרבים ונפל לתוכו שור או חמור ומת חייב

(a)

(Mishnah): If one dug a pit in the Reshus ha'Rabim, and an animal fell in, he is liable;

אחד החופר בור ושיח ומערה חריצים ונעיצין

1.

The law is the same for a circular pit, a long and thin pit, a covered cave, or a pit that is wider at top than at bottom.

[דף כא עמוד ב (עוז והדר)] א''כ למה נאמר בור אלא מה הבור [דף כה עמוד א] שהוא כדי להמית עד עשרה טפחים אף כל דבר שהוא כדי להמית עד עשרה טפחים

2.

If so, why did the Torah say Bor (a standard pit)? It teaches that just like a pit is 10 Tefachim deep, which can kill, in all cases one is liable for 10 Tefachim.

היו פחותין מעשרה טפחים ונפל לתוכו שור או חמור ומת פטור ואם הוזק בו חייב

3.

If it was less than 10 Tefachim, and an ox or donkey fell in, if it died, he is exempt. If it was damaged, he is liable.

החופר בור ברשות היחיד ופתחו לר''ה בר''ה ופתחו לרשות היחיד ברה''י ופתחו לרה''י אחר חייב:

(b)

If one digs a pit in a Reshus ha'Yachid, and its opening is to Reshus ha'Rabim, or in a Reshus ha'Rabim, and its opening is to a Reshus ha'Yachid, or in Reshus ha'Yachid and its opening is to a different Reshus ha'Yachid, he is liable.

גמ' כתיב [שמות כא לג] כי יפתח איש בור וכי יכרה איש בור

(c)

(Gemara) Question: Why it is written "Ki Yiftach Ish Bor'' and "Ki Yichreh Ish Bor'' (why is Bor repeated)?

אחד בור לנזקין ואחד בור למיתה.

(d)

Answer: One teaches about a pit for Misah (10 Tefachim deep), and one teaches about a pit for damage.

1.

Note: Above (1:2), Tana'im argued about whether the Shi'ur for damage is any amount, or three Tefachim deep and four Tefachim long and wide, or the size of what fell.

א''ר יצחק אחד בור של מיתה ואחד בור לנזקין שניהן ממקרא אחד נתרבו.

(e)

(R. Yitzchak): The same applies to a pit for Misah and a pit for damage. Both were included from one verse;

וכשהוא בא לבור של מיתה את מר פטור על הכלים וכשהוא בא לבור של נזקין את מר חייב על הכלים.

1.

When it comes to (i.e. regarding) a pit for Misah, it was taught that one is exempt for Kelim. When it comes to a pit for damage, it was taught that one is liable for Kelim. (This is unlike the Bavli, which exempts both of them for Kelim - RASHBA 3a DH Sof.)

אין לי אלא בשחפר לקח ירש ניתן לו במתנה מניין

(f)

Question: [From the verse] I know only if he dug [the pit]. If he bought or inherited it, what is the source [to obligate him]?

שנאמר [שמות כא לג] או כי יכרה איש בור.

(g)

Answer: We learn from "Oh Ki Yichreh Ish Bor'' (it is extra, to include this. Sotah 13a expounds Kirah to be an expression of Mechirah (sale) - PF.)

וכי יש לו רשות להפקיר נזקיו ברשות הרבים

(h)

Question: (One cannot inherit part of Reshus ha'Rabim. Surely, he inherited a pit in Reshus ha'Yachid, and he was Mafkir the Reshus - HA'GAON RAV C. KANIEVSKY, SHLITA.) May one make his Nezikin Hefker in Reshus ha'Rabim?!

אמר רבי יוסי בי ר' בון תיפתר כר' יוסי בי רבי יהודה דאמר שלשה (דברים) [צ''ל טפחים - רידב''ז] שהן סמוכין לרשות כרשות.

(i)

Answer (R. Yosi bei R. Bun): It is like R. Yosi b'Ribi Yehudah, who says that three Tefachim next to a Reshus are like the Reshus. (We explained this like RIDVAZ.)

ר' מנא בעי מהו שיעשה את העומק כגובה.

(j)

Question (R. Mana): Is depth like height? (SEDEI YEHOSHUA - an elevation from which one can fall, is one liable for it like for a pit? Shmuel (obligates for a pit even for impacting the ground, even though he did nothing to acquire the ground or make it a damager; he merely exposed it and caused the victim to fall on it and be damaged through it. The same applies to a mound from which one can fall. Rav holds that one is liable only for the dank air of a pit, which the digger created. If so, one is exempt for a mound. GILYONEI HA'SHAS - the Yerushalmi should have said 'is height like depth?' It said 'is depth like height?', for this expression is frequent in the Yerushalmi.)

והיכי דמי אין בהוא דאתי מן עיל חמי ליה.

1.

Question: What is the case? If [the victim] came from the elevated side, it saw it [and should not have gone there. There is no liability in such a case!]

אלא בההוא דאתי מן לרע:

2.

Answer: It came from the side on which there is a small slope.