MENACHOS 7 29 Teves) - Dedicated in honor of the Yahrzeit of Jeri (Gittel) Turkel, who passed away on 29 Teves 5777, by her husband, Eli Turkel. The memory of Jeri's vibrant energy, her fervent prayers and her thirst for learning are cherished by all who knew her.
1)

AVIMI WENT TO LEARN FROM HIS TALMID

רבי אבימי תני מנחות בי רב חסדא ואבימי בי רב חסדא תני והאמר רב חסדא קולפי טבי בלעי מאבימי עלה דהא שמעתא בא להכריז רצופין ל' יום שני וחמישי ושני ס' יום אבימי מסכתא איתעקורי איתעקרא ליה ואתא קמיה דרב חסדא לאדכורי לגמריה ולישלח ליה וליתי לגביה סבר הכי מסתייעא מילתא טפי:
Translation: Avimi was learning Menachos in Rav Chisda's residence... How can that be? Rav Chisda was a Talmid of Avimi (the following proves this)! Rav Chisda said, I swallowed many blows from Avimi about the teaching 'if they announce consecutively, it is 30 days. If they announce only on Mondays and Thursdays, it is 60 days. The case is, Avimi had forgotten Maseches Menachos. He went to Rav Chisda, who helped him to recover it. He could have told his Talmid to come to him! Avimi went, for this helps to succeed.
(a)

Question: What is the meaning of 'I swallowed many blows from Avimi'?

1.

Rashi (according to Hagahos in Oz v'Hadar edition): Rav Chisda forgot the answer, and Avimi struck (or embarrassed or reminded) him many times.

(b)

What was the teaching about announcing consecutively, or on Mondays and Thursdays?

1.

Rashi: A Mishnah says that Beis Din announces orphans' property for 30 days before selling it. A Beraisa says, it is 60 days! Avimi answered that the former is when they announce consecutively (every weekday); the latter is when they announce only on Mondays and Thursdays.

(c)

Why does going to his Talmid help to succeed?

1.

Rashi: If one says 'Yagati u'Matzasi' (I toiled and found understanding of Torah, believe him)' (Megilah 6b).

i.

Daf Al ha'Daf citing Mishnas R. Aharon (1, Amelah Shel Torah): Hash-m promised that one who toils in Torah will merit to understand more than based on his aptitude. Therefore, it is called Metzi'ah (a found object). This is even for preparation to learn (going to his Talmid). Perhaps the same applies to preparation for Tefilah.

ii.

Chashukei Chemed: For this reason, it is better to go to a Shi'ur than to hear it on the phone, even if he loses time going to and returning from the Shi'ur. Also, this strengthens those who go to the Shi'ur, when they see more people there. Amelus in Torah is exertion in learning itself. Yegi'ah is in preparations to learn. This brings help from Shamayim to understand, but only Amelus makes the Torah part of the person himself. Mishnas R. Aharon (1, p. 39) says that Avimi's primary Yegi'ah was the humility to go to learn from his Talmid. One who toils for Torah covertly, a Bris promises that he will not forget quickly (Yerushalmi Berachos 5:!). This is because he learns Lishmah, without external support.

2.

Ha'Boneh: Torah is dear to those who learn it. It is dearer if they toiled for it, and they remember it better.