MEGILAH 24 (8 Av) - Dedicated l'Iluy Nishmas Mrs. Lily (Leah bas Pinchas) Kornfeld, who passed away on 8 Av 5765, by her daughter and son-in-law, Diane and Andy Koenigsberg and family. May Lily and her husband's love for Torah and for Eretz Yisrael continue in all of their descendants.

1)

(a)Our Mishnah now discusses the number of Pesukim that are read. What is ...

1. ... the minimum number of Pesukim that one may read per Aliyah?

2. ... the maximum number of Pesukim that the Ba'al Korei may read from the Torah for the translator to translate?

(b)One may normally read three Pesukim to a translator from the Navi. On what condition may one only read one?

(c)What is one permitted to do in the Navi, that is not permitted to do in the Torah?

1)

(a)Our Mishnah now discusses the number of Pesukim that are read in the Torah.

1. The minimum number of Pesukim that one may read per Aliyah - is three.

2. The maximum number of Pesukim that the Ba'al Korei may read from the Torah for the translator to translate - is one.

(b)One may normally read three Pesukim to a translator from the Navi, but only one - when it is a Parashah on its own.

(c)One is permitted to jump from one Parashah to another in the Navi - although this is not permitted in the Torah.

2)

(a)What reason does Rav Asi give for the minimum of three Pesukim per Aliyah?

(b)In which Navi do we find three consecutive Pesukim that comprise three different Parshiyos?

2)

(a)The reason that Rav Asi gives for the minimum of three Pesukim per Aliyah - is that it corresponds to Torah, Nevi'im and Kesuvim (the same reason that he himself gave above on 21b. for the three Aliyos on Monday, Thursday and Shabbos Minchah).

(b)We find three consecutive Pesukim comprising three different Parshiyos - in Yeshayah (Chapter 52, Pesukim 3, 4 and 5).

3)

(a)Our Mishnah forbids jumping from one place to another in the Torah. When in fact, is this done?

(b)Abaye attempts to reconcile this with our Mishnah by confining it to when one does take longer than it takes for the translator to finish the translation of the previous Pasuk. On what grounds do we reject that suggestion?

(c)How does Abaye finally reconcile the Mishnah in Yoma with our Mishnah?

(d)Under what condition is one permitted to jump even from one Sefer in Navi to another?

3)

(a)Our Mishnah forbids jumping from one place to another in the Torah. In fact, this is done - by the Kohen Gadol on Yom Kippur (when he first reads the Parashah of Yom Kippur in Acharei-Mos and then the Parashah of Yom Kippur in Emor).

(b)Abaye attempts to reconcile this with our Mishnah by confining it to when rolling from one place to another does not take longer than it takes for the translator to finish the translation of the previous Pasuk. We reject that contention however - on the grounds that our Mishnah permits even jumping from place to another in the Navi only on that condition, yet it still forbids jumping in the Chumash.

(c)Abaye finally reconciles the Mishnah in Yoma with our Mishnah - by confining the concession there to where one remains in the same topic (e.g. from Yom Kippur to Yom Kippur. It also goes without saying that there, like in the Navi, it is only permitted if they finish rolling before the translator has finished his translation).

(d)One is permitted to jump even from one Sefer to another in Navi - in the Trei-Asar, provided one rolls forward and not backwards.

4)

(a)The person who generally gets Maftir is Poreis al Shema and Davens before the Amud. Which third privilege does he enjoy (provided he is a Kohen)?

(b)What happens if he is a Katan?

(c)A Katan is permitted to read both the Haftarah and in the Torah. Is he permitted to ...

1. ... be Poreis al Shema?

2. ... Daven or Duchen?

4)

(a)The person who generally gets Maftir receives three privileges. He is Poreis al Shema, he Davens before the Amud - and, if he is a Kohen, he leads the Duchening.

(b)If he is a Katan - then (with regard to the first two) his father or his Rebbe receive the privilege instead of him.

(c)A Katan is permitted to read both the Haftarah and in the Torah - he may not however ...

1. ... be Poreis al Shema ...

2. ... or Daven (since he is himself not Chayav); nor may he Duchen on his own (see also Tosfos DH 've'Ein'), because it is not respectful for the Tzibur to have to rely on a Katan for a Berachah.

5)

(a)What is a 'Poche'ach'?

(b)Why does our Mishnah forbids him to read, to Daven before the Amud or to Duchen?

(c)Is he permitted to be Poreis al Shema and to to translate?

(d)According to the Tana Kama, a blind man is permitted to be Poreis al Shema and to translate. What does Rebbi Yehudah say?

5)

(a)A 'Poche'ach' is - someone whose legs are not covered.

(b)Our Mishnah forbids him to Lein, to Daven before the Amud or to Duchen - the former because it is not Kavod Torah, the latter two, because it is a disgrace for the Tzibur to have such a Shali'ach Tzibur.

(c)The Tana - does however, permit him to be Poreis al Shema and to translate.

(d)According to the Tana Kama, a blind man is permitted to be Poreis al Shema and to translate. Rebbi Yehudah says - that if he was blind from birth, he cannot be Poreis al Shema.

6)

(a)Rav Papa explains that the person who reads Maftir receives the three above-mentioned privileges as a matter of Kavod. What does this mean?

(b)What reason does Rabah bar Shimi give for the privileges?

(c)What is the difference between the two explanations? When will the one apply and the other not?

6)

(a)Rav Papa explains that the person who reads Maftir receives the three above-mentioned privileges as a matter of Kavod - meaning that, because he volunteers to perform the least important of all the Mitzvos, we compensate him by honoring him with the three privileges.

(b)Rabah bar Shimi gives the reason for the privileges - as being in order to avoid a squabble (he will claim that, if someone else receives Musaf [for example], it is unfair that he only received Maftir and the second person gets Musaf.

(c)The difference between the two answers - will manifest itself in a place where the Chazan does not get paid for Davenning Musaf. In that case, the person who received Maftir will not pick a fight because of that (nevertheless, if it is a matter of Kavod, then he must be compensated).

24b----------------------------------------24b

7)

(a)Ula bar Rav asked Abaye whether a Katan Poche'ach is permitted to read in the Torah. What makes us think that a might be?

(b)On what grounds did Abaye reply that he is not?

(c)Rebbi Yehudah in our Mishnah forbids a blind man who has never seen, from being Poreis al Shema. What does he answer the Rabanan, who ask him how he can then permit the reading of the Ma'aseh ha'Merkavah for the Haftarah (see Mishnah 24a.), seeing as most people cannot understand it?

7)

(a)Ula bar Rav asked Abaye whether a Katan Poche'ach is permitted to read in the Torah - because he is not included in the warning "v'Lo Yir'eh B'cha Ervas Davar" (the source for the prohibition of a Poche'ach reading in the Torah).

(b)Abaye replied that he is not - for the same reason that Ula bar Rav evidently does not permit a naked Katan to read in the Torah. In that case, neither is a Poche'ach (seeing as there is no logical reason to differentiate between them).

(c)Rebbi Yehudah in our Mishnah forbids a blind man who has never seen, from being Poreis al Shema. He answers the Rabanan, who ask him how he can then permit the reading of the Ma'aseh ha'Merkavah for the Haftarah (see Mishnah 24a.), seeing as most people cannot understand it - by pointing out that, at least there, it is possible to study and understand it, whereas in the case of the blind man, it is impossible for him to appreciate the light of the sun, ever.

8)

(a)What problem did Rebbi Yosi in a Beraisa have with the Pasuk in Ki Savo "v'Hayisa Memashesh ba'Tzohorayim ... "?

(b)What happened to Rebbi Yosi one night that helped him to understand the Pasuk?

(c)How do the Rabanan use this Beraisa to explain why even someone who is born blind can be Poreis al Shema?

8)

(a)The problem Rebbi Yosi in a Beraisa had with the Pasuk in Ki Savo "v'Hayisa Memashesh ba'Tzohorayim Ka'asher Yemashesh ha'Iver ba'Afeilah ... " is - that, seeing as we are talking about a blind man, what is the difference whether he is groping his way at night-time or by day? ...

(b)... until one night - when he approached a blind man and asked him why he was holding a torch, since he could not see anyway; to which the blind man replied that, when people would see him at night with a torch in his hand, they would come and help him on his way (something that they could not do if was not holding a torch). So Rebbi Yosi understood that the Pasuk added the word "at night-time" because then, nobody will help him out of his predicament.

(c)In any event, we see from Rebbi Yosi - that, even if somebody is born blind, in which case he cannot see or appreciate the light of the sun directly, it is possible for him to benefit from it indirectly (through the services of others who guide him along the way). And that is good reason for him to be able to recite the Berachah of 'Yotzer ha'Me'oros' and even to be Motzi others.

9)

(a)The Tana Kama forbids a Kohen who has blemished hands to Duchen. What does ...

1. ... Rebbi Yehudah add to blemished hands?

2. ... the Tana of the Beraisa add to blemished hands?

(b)Rebbi Yehoshua ben Levi adds a Kohen who has white blotches on his hands. Which two blemishes does the Beraisa add to that?

(c)Why were men from Haifa, Beis Sha'an and Tiv'on disqualified from Duchening?

(d)What did Rebbi retort, when Rebbi Chiya told his son Rebbi Shimon that, if had he been a Levi, he would have been Pasul from singing because he had a thick voice?

9)

(a)The Tana Kama forbids a Kohen who has blemished hands to Duchen.

1. Rebbi Yehudah adds to blemished hands - hands that are covered with paint.

2. The Tana of the Beraisa adds to blemished hands - a blemished face and feet.

(b)Rebbi Yehoshua ben Levi adds a Kohen who has white blotches on his hands, to which the Beraisa adds - someone whose hands are crooked or bent to the side.

(c)Men from Haifa, Beis Sha'an and Tiv'on were disqualified from Duchening - because they tended to confuse the pronunciation of the 'Aleph' and the 'Ayin'.

(d)When Rebbi Chiya told Rebbi's son Rebbi Shimon that, had he been a Levi, he would have been disqualified from singing because he had a thick voice - he instructed him to go and ask Rebbi Chiya (who would pronounce a 'Hey' instead of a 'Ches') what he intended to do when he arrived at the Pasuk in Yeshayah "v'Chikeisi la'Hashem" (which he would read as "v'Hikeisi la'Shem" - a tremendous blasphemy).

10)

(a)Seeing as Rav Huna disqualifies a blear-eyed Kohen (who constantly sheds tears) from Duchening, and Rebbi Yochanan, a Kohen who is blind in one eye, how is it that Rav Huna said nothing about a blear-eyed Kohen who Duchened in his vicinity, and neither did Rebbi Yochanan, with regard to a Kohen who was blind in one eye and who Duchened in his vicinity?

(b)Under what circumstances does Rebbi Yehudah permit a Kohen whose hands are covered with paint to Duchen?

10)

(a)Despite the fact that Rav Huna disqualifies a blear-eyed Kohen (who constantly sheds tears) from Duchening, and Rebbi Yochanan, a Kohen who is blind in one eye - they both opted to remain silent (when a blear-eyed Kohen Duchened in the vicinity of the former, and a Kohen who was blind in one eye in the vicinity of the latter - because in both cases, the people of the town had gotten used to him, and would not look at him anyway (which is the real reason for the prohibition).

(b)Rebbi Yehudah permits a Kohen whose hands are covered with paint to Duchen - provided most of the other residents are in the paint business too.

11)

(a)Why is someone who refuses to go down to the Amud to Daven with colored clothes (or with shoes), forbidden to go down with white clothes (or barefoot)?

(b)What are the two reasons for which the Tana forbids wearing round Tefilin?

(c)He also describes someone placing Tefilin shel Rosh or the shel Yad on the wrong spot as Derech ha'Minus. What is he referring to? Where must the 'Min' place his Tefilin in order to earn such a title?

(d)Why does the Tana call it 'Derech ha'Chitzonim' (who follow their own minds) if one ...

1. ... overlays the Tefilin with gold?

2. ... places the Tefilin shel Yad on top of his sleeve?

11)

(a)Someone who refuses to go down to the Amud to Daven with colored clothes (or with shoes), is forbidden to go down even with white clothes (or barefoot) - because we are afraid that he has a streak of Minus (heresy).

(b)The two reasons that the Tana forbids wearing round Tefilin - are either because it constitutes danger, or because they are Pasul because they are misshapen.

(c)He also describes someone who places either the Tefilin shel Rosh or the shel Yad on the wrong spot as Derech ha'Minus - the former on his forehead (in front of the hair-line); the latter, on the palm of his hand.

(d)The Tana calls it 'Derech ha'Chitzonim' (who follow their own minds) if one ...

1. ... overlays the Tefilin with gold - because the Torah requires the Tefilin to be made of the skin of a Kasher animal, and not of gold (since the Torah writes "Lema'an Tih'yeh Toras Hash-m b'Ficha". From the Gemara in Makos however, it appears that it is 'Halachah l'Moshe mi'Sinai').

2. ... places the Tefilin shel Yad on top of his sleeve - because the Torah writes "v'Haya Lecha l'Os .. " from which Chazal Darshen "Lecha l'Os" 'v'Lo la'Acheirim l'Os".

12)

(a)The Beraisa requires Tefilin to be square. What is the source for this?

(b)Which two ramifications does Rava extrapolate from this Halachah?

(c)Why is our Mishnah, which forbids round Tefilin because they are not a Mitzvah, not necessarily a proof for the Tana of the Beraisa?

12)

(a)The Beraisa requires Tefilin to be square - 'Halachah l'Moshe mi'Sinai'.

(b)Rava extrapolate two Halachos from here - a. that the Tefilin must be square (and not distorted by pulling the thread with which they are sewn taught) and b. that they must be literally square and not oblong (a minimum of one fingers-breadth by one fingers-breadth, with a diagonal of one and two-fifth finger-breadths).

(c)Our Mishnah, which forbids round Tefilin because they are not a Mitzvah, is not a proof for the Tana of the Beraisa - because our Mishnah could be speaking about Tefilin that are oval like an egg (but if they are round like a wall-nut, perhaps they are Kasher).

OTHER D.A.F. RESOURCES
ON THIS DAF