13th CYCLE DEDICATIONS:

ERUVIN 26 (23 Nisan) - dedicated l'Iluy Nishmas the father of Mr. Avy Reichman Z'L of Queens, NY, Dovid ben Avraham Z'L, by Avy's children.

1)

THREE HALACHOS IN THE NAME OF R. ELIEZER (Yerushalmi Perek 2 Halachah 8 Daf 17b)

מתני' א"ר אילעאי שמעתי מרבי אליעזר אפילו היא כבית כור

(a)

(Mishnah - R. Ila'i): I heard that R. Eliezer permits up to a Beis Kor.

וכן שמעתי ממנו אנשי חצר ששכח אחד מהן ולא עירב ביתו אסור מלהכניס ומלהוציא לו אבל להן מותר

(b)

I (R. Ila'i) also heard from [R. Eliezer] that if one forgot to give towards the Eruv in the Chatzer [and on Shabbos he was Mevatel (ceded his ownership) to the Bnei Chatzer], his house is forbidden to him (to transfer between it and the Chatzer), but it is permitted for them (Bnei Chatzer may transfer between their houses and his, via the Chatzer);

וכן שמעתי ממנו שיוצאין בערקבנין בפסח וחיזרתי על כל תלמידיו ובקשתי לי חבר ולא מצאתי:

(c)

I also heard from him that one fulfils [the Mitzvah of Maror] on Pesach with Arkavlnn (palm-ivy). I pursued all his Talmidim to find someone else [who heard these Halachos from him], and I did not find.

גמ' רבי אבהו בשם רבי אלעזר במחלקת סאתים מבית כור היא מתני':

(d)

(Gemara - R. Avahu citing R. Elazar): Like the conditions [in which the previous Mishnah permits] Sa'atayim (it may not be more than, and the length may not exceed the width even by one Amah, so is the Heter in) our Mishnah for a Beis Kor.

וכן שמעתי ממנו אנשי חצר ששכח אחד מהן ולא עירב ביתו אסור:

(e)

Implied question (Mishnah): And so I heard from him that if one of the Bnei Chatzer forgot and was not Me'arev, his house is forbidden [... but it is permitted for them. A Mishnah below (6:3) forbids everyone!]

תמן רבנן ברם הכא ר' אליעזר

(f)

Answer: That is Rabanan. Here is R. Eliezer;

רבנן אמרי אדם מבטל רשות (ביתו ואין אדם מבטל רשות חצירו) [צ"ל חצירו ואין אדם מבטל רשות ביתו - קרבן העדה] רבי אליעזר אומר כשם שאדם מבטל רשות (ביתו כך מבטל רשות חצירו) [צ"ל חצירו כן מבטל רשות ביתו - קרבן העדה]

1.

Rabanan say that one [who is Mevatel Stam, he] is Mevatel Reshus of his Chatzer, but one is not Mevatel Reshus of his house [therefore it is forbidden even to them]. R. Eliezer says that just like he is Mevatel Reshus of his Chatzer, he is Mevatel Reshus of his house.

על דעתיה דרבי אליעזר ייעשה כאכסנא ויהא מותר

(g)

Question: According to R. Eliezer, [the Mevatel] should be like a guest [of the others], and he should be permitted!

ר' חייה בר אדא בשם רשב"ל קנס קנסו רבי אליעזר.

(h)

Answer (R. Chiya bar Ada citing Reish Lakish): (According to letter of the law, you are correct.) R. Eliezer made a fine.

[דף יח עמוד א] רבי שמי בעי דבר מדבריהן קונסין לו בשוגג כר' ליעזר

(i)

Question (R. Shamai): If one transgressed any matter mid'Rabanan, b'Shogeg, does R. Eliezer fine him?

ר' בא בריה דרב פפי בעי אמר הריני מבטל רשות ביתי אוף רבנן מודיי

(j)

Question (R. Ba brei d'Rav Papi): If one said 'I am Mevatel Reshus of my house', do even Rabanan agree [that Bnei Chatzer are permitted? Above we said that they argue only about Stam, whether he intended also for Bitul of Reshus Beiso. Or, perhaps Batlah Daito Etzel Kol Adam, i.e. we ignore his mindset, since it is unlike that of normal people.]

(א"ר) [צ"ל אמר - קרבן העדה] הריני מבטל רשות חצירי אוף רב ליעזר מודה:

(k)

If one said 'I am Mevatel Reshus of my Chatzer', even R. Eliezer agrees [that Bnei Chatzer are forbidden].

וכן שמעתי ממנו שיוצאין בערקבנין בפסח.

(l)

(Mishnah): And so I heard from him, that one fulfils [Mitzvas Maror] on Pesach with Arkavnin. [I did not find someone else who heard so from him.]

הוינן סברין מימר בערקבנין אשכח תני על כולהן:

(m)

We thought to say that [R. Ila'i] did not find someone else who heard so from R. Eliezer regarding Arkavnin. A Beraisa was found teaching so about all of these Halachos [in the name of R. Eliezer, i.e. also permitting up to a Beis Kor, and one who forgot to be Me'arev].

HADRAN ALACH PEREK OSEH PASIN

OTHER D.A.F. RESOURCES
ON THIS DAF