Bechoros Chart #7
Chart for Bechoros Daf 21a
THE ARGUMENT BETWEEN REBBI SHIMON AND THE TANA KAMA ACCORDING TO RASHI AND TOSFOS
| (A) RASHI'S FIRST EXPLANATION |
(B) RASHI'S SECOND EXPLANATION |
(C) RASHI'S THIRD EXPLANATION |
(D) TOSFOS |
||
| 1 | "WITHIN A YEAR" -- OF WHAT? |
Tinuf | Her own birth | Tinuf | Her own birth |
| 2 | "THEY ARGUE ABOUT ZE'IRI'S LAW" -- WHICH ANIMAL HAD "TINUF"? | Daughters | Mother | Daughters | Mother (1) Daughters (2) |
| 3 | WHEN DID THE "TINUF" OCCUR? | At the end of 6 months after birth | At the start of the 7th month | At the start of the 7th month (3) | At birth of mother (1) At birth of daughters (2) |
| 4 | WHAT DO WE INFER FROM R. SHIMON'S WORDS? | "b'Soch Shenasah" implies long before the end of the year | He does not specify that each daughter bore 3 more children | "b'Soch Shenasah" implies within 12 months (and not during the leap month) | "she'Israh Toch Shenasah" implies that the mother was also part of the Ma'aser count |
-------------------------------------------------