Our Mishnah means that [if it died after the lottery,] he brings two and makes a lottery on them from the beginning. [He does not say "if the one of Hash-m died.'' Rather, if that one died,] he says "this on which the lot for Hash-m fell, it will be in place of it.''

Question: [When that of Azazel died, and there are two for Hash-m,] which is offered first? (Both are offered. One will be the inner goat, and the other grazes, and after it is blemished we offer Nedavah with its redemption money.)

Answer #1 (Rav): The second (the one for Hash-m) in the second pair [is the inner goat.]

Answer #2 (R. Yochanan): The second (the one for Hash-m) in the first pair [is the inner goat.]

Opinion #1 (R. Ze'irah): R. Yochanan learns from "v'Asahu Chatas'' - the first one. (This is extra, for it already said "v'Hikriv.'' We explained this according to RIDVAZ.)

Opinion #2 (R. La): R. Yochanan learns that "v'Asahu Chatas'' fixes [the first one, even] if it is suspended (e.g. if the other dies), that it will not be Nidcheh.

Support: This is like R. Yonah in the name of R. Ze'irah (and unlike R. Ze'irah himself said above) - "v'Asahu Chatas'' fixes if it is suspended, that we get a mate for it (through another lottery).

Question: According to R. Yochanan, if the second of the first pair died, the second in the second pair, is it Nidcheh?

Answer (R. Ba citing R. Chiyah citing R. Yochanan): If the second of the first pair died, the second in the second pair, is already Nidcheh (from when the lot came on it, since at the time the corresponding goat of the first pair was alive).

All the more so, the opposite way according to Rav, if the second in the second pair died, the second of the first pair was [initially Kosher, and] already Nidcheh (when its mate died. It does not become Kosher again! We explained this like SHA'AREI TORAS ERETZ YISRAEL and HA'GAON RAV C. KANIEVSKY, SHLITA.)

Question: If one made lotteries on three pairs, and put from one between the staves, from one on the Paroches, and from one on the inner Mizbe'ach, [the mate of] which is the Se'ir ha'Mishtale'ach?

Answer #1 (R. Ze'irah): "Lechaper Alav'' - the one through which he is Mechaper, its mate is sent. One through which he is not Mechaper, its mate is not sent.

Answer #2 (R. Heila): "Lechaper Alav'' - the one through which he completes the Kaparah, its mate is sent. One through which he does not complete the Kaparah, its mate is not sent.

Explanation: According to R. Ze'irah, all three of them are sent. According to R. Heila, only the last is sent.