Perek bi'Sheloshah Perakim
1)
(a)The Tana lists three occasions in the year on which the Kohanim Duchen four times (a statement which we will later amend). What are ...
1. ... the three occasions?
2. ... the four times?
(b)Besides the closing of the gates of the Beis Hamikdash, what else can 'Ne'ilas She'arim' mean?
(c)What do we learn from the Pasuk in Pinchas "Tzav es Bnei Yisrael ... es Korbani Lachmi ... "?
(d)Who instituted the Ma'amados?
1)
(a)The Tana lists three occasions in the year on which the Kohanim Duchen four times (a statement which we will later amend). The ...
1. ... three occasions - are on Ta'aniyos, Ma'amados and Yom Kippur.
2. ... four times - are Shacharis, Musaf, Minchah and Ne'ilah.
(b)Besides the closing of the gates of the Beis Hamikdash - 'Ne'ilas She'arim' can also mean the closing of the gates of Heaven (which close after Yisrael have Davened Minchah).
(c)We learn from the Pasuk in Pinchas "Tzav es Bnei Yisrael ... es Korbani Lachmi ... " - that Yisrael are the owners of the Korban Tamid, and that (since it is not correct for someone's Korban to be brought in his absence), they must appoint representatives to stand by the Tamid whenever it is brought.
(d)The early prophets (Shmuel and David) - instituted the Ma'amados.
2)
(a)The Ma'amados correspond to the twenty-four Mishmaros. Where were they situated?
(b)Which three things did the men of the Ma'amad in the towns used to do?
(c)On which days of the week would they fast?
(d)What did they Lein ...
1. ... on Sunday?
2. ... on Monday?
3. ... on Friday?
2)
(a)The Ma'amados correspond to the twenty-four Mishmaros. There were Ma'amados - both in Yerushalayim and in the other towns of Yisrael.
(b)The men of the Ma'amad in the towns used to - Daven that the Korban Tamid should be accepted, fast, and Lein.
(c)They would fast from Monday through Thursday.
(d)They would Lein ...
1. ... on Sunday - "Bereishis" and "Yehi Raki'a".
2. ... on Monday - "Yehi Raki'a" and "Yikavu ha'Mayim".
3. ... on Friday - "va'Totzei ha'Aretz" and "va'Yechulu" (all from the Parashah of Bereishis).
3)
(a)Why did they need to Lein two Parshiyos each day?
(b)How did they arrange the three Aliyos?
(c)How often did they Lein each day?
(d)At which Tefilah on Friday did the men of the Ma'amad not gather to Lein?
3)
(a)They needed to Lein two Parshiyos each day - because they did not have the required number of Pesukim (ten, or at least nine) in either of the individual Parshiyos.
(b)They arranged the three Aliyos - by calling up two for the bigger Parashah, and one for the smaller.
(c)They Leined each day - at Shacharis, Musaf and Minchah.
(d)The men of the Ma'amad did not gather to Lein - at Minchah on Friday, because of Kevod Shabbos.
4)
(a)What would the men of the Ma'amad in Yerushalayim omit on a day when Halel was recited?
(b)Why would they omit ...
1. ... Ma'amados at Ne'ilah, on a day when the Korban Musaf was brought?
2. ... Ma'amados at Minchah, on a day when the Korban Etzim was brought?
(c)What is the difference between the two cases?
4)
(a)On a day when Halel was recited (i.e. Chanukah - Tosfos DH 'be'Chol') - the men of the Ma'amad would omit the Ma'amad of Shacharis (i.e. Davening for their brothers' Korbanos to be accepted).
(b)They would omit ...
1. ... Ma'amados at Ne'ilah, on a day when the Korban Musaf was brought - because they were busy on account of the extra Korbanos that the Musaf comprised (at least two lambs - on Shabbos). It goes without saying that the Ma'amados at Minchah were also omitted.
2. ... Ma'amados at Minchah, on a day when the Korban Etzim was brought - because the Korban that accompanied the donation of wood kept them busy.
(c)In the latter case however - they did recite the Ma'amados at Ne'ilah.
5)
(a)If the Kohanim of the Ma'amad (who were apparently chosen from the Mishmar of that week) were Patur because they were busy bringing the Musafim, why were the Yisraelim Patur?
(b)This is the opinion of Rebbi Akiva. What does ben Azai say?
(c)Whom does ben Azai quote?
(d)What did Rebbi Akiva say when he heard ben Azai quoting R. Yehoshua?
5)
(a)The Kohanim of the Ma'amad (who were apparently chosen from the Mishmar of that week) were Patur - because they were busy bringing the Musafim; the Yisraelim - because they were busy chopping wood and drawing water for the needs of the Korban. Note, that the Givonim performed these tasks for the Kohanim's personal needs, but not for Hash-m's (i.e. for the Korbanos) - Tosfos Yom-Tov.
(b)This is the opinion of Rebbi Akiva. ben Azai reverses the Halachos: according to him - whenever there was a Korban Musaf, they omitted the Ma'amad at Minchah (but not at Ne'ilah), whereas when there was a Korban Etzim, they omitted the Ma'amad at Ne'ilah, too.
(c)ben Azai quotes - Rebbi Yehoshua.
(d)When Rebbi Akiva heard ben Azai quoting R. Yehoshua - he conceded that he was right.
6)
(a)Zman Atzei Kohanim v'ha'Am comprised nine fixed days in the year. What happened on those nine days?
(b)On what basis were those particular families chosen?
(c)The family of Orach ben Yehudah was the first family to bring wood. What was their designated date?
(d)Which was the second family to bring the Korban Etzim (on the twentieth of Tamuz)?
6)
(a)Zman Atzei Kohanim v'ha'Am comprised nine fixed days in the year - on which certain designated families donated wood each year for the Korbanos, together with which they would bring a Korban of wood.
(b)Those particular families were chosen - on the basis of their having stepped forward and donated wood (on those same dates) when it was needed (after Yisrael returned from Bavel and re-built the second Beis Hamikdash).
(c)The family of Orach ben Yehudah was the first to bring the Korban Etzim; their designated date being - the first of Nisan.
(d)The second family to bring the Korban Etzim (on the twentieth of Tamuz) - was that of David ben Yehudah (alias David ha'Melech).
7)
(a)What do the Bnei Zeisu ben Yehudah, the Bnei Gonvei Ali and the Bnei Kotzei Ketzios all have in common?
(b)Who else brought the Korban Etzim together with them on the fifteenth of Av?
(c)Before them, the Bnei Parosh ben Yehudah, the Bnei Yonadav ben Rechav (descendents of Yisro) and the Bnei Sanav ben Binyamin also brought wood, also in the month of Av. On which respective day in Av did each of them bring?
(d)The Bnei Pachas Mo'av ben Yehudah brought on the same day in Av as the Bnei Adin ben Yehudah brought in Elul. Which day was it?
(e)The last family on the list was that of Parosh ben Yehudah, who brought the Korban Etzim on Rosh Chodesh Teves. What distinction marked ...
1. ... Parosh ben Yehudah from all the other families?
2. ... Rosh Chodesh Teves from all the other dates?
7)
(a)What the Bnei Zeisu ben Yehudah, the Bnei Gonvei Ali and the Bnei Kotz'ei Ketzios had in common was - that they were all one and the same.
(b)Kohanim and Leviyim, as well as anyone who did not know to which tribe he belonged - brought the Korban Etzim together with them on the fifteenth of Av.
(c)Before them, the Bnei Parosh ben Yehudah, the Bnei Yonadav ben Rechav (descendents of Yisro) and the Bnei Sanav ben Binyamin also brought wood - on the fifth, the seventh and the tenth, respectively.
(d)The Bnei Pachas Mo'av ben Yehudah brought on - the twentieth of Av, and the Bnei Adin ben Yehudah on the twentieth of Elul.
(e)The last family on the list was that of Parosh ben Yehudah, who brought the Korban Etzim on Rosh Chodesh Teves. The distinction that marked ...
1. ... Parosh ben Yehudah from all the other families - was the fact that they were the only one to donate twice.
2. ... Rosh Chodesh Teves from all the other dates - was the fact that (since both the Korban Musaf and a Korban Etzim were brought on it) no Ma'amados were said.
26b----------------------------------------26b
8)
(a)Which two calamities ...
1. ... (besides the smashing of the Luchos, the nullification of the Tamid and the breaching of the walls of Yerushalayim) occurred on Shiv'ah-Asar b'Tamuz?
2. ... (besides the decree that the generation that left Egypt would not enter Eretz Yisrael and the destruction of both Batei Mikdash) occurred on Tisha b'Av?
(b)What do we do when Av enters?
(c)Which two things does the Tana of our Mishnah forbid during the week of Tisha b'Av?
(d)Which of them is permitted on Thursday and on what condition?
8)
(a)The two calamities ...
1. ... (besides the smashing of the Luchos, the nullification of the Tamid and the breaching of the walls of Yerushalayim in the time of the first Beis-Hamikdash) that occurred on Shiv'ah-Asar b'Tamuz - were 1. Apostomos (a Greek officer) burned the Torah (possibly the Sefer Torah that Ezra wrote - see Tiferes Yisrael), and 2. An image was placed in the Heichal, in the time of the first Beis Hamikdash.
2. ... (besides the decree that the generation that left Egypt would not enter Eretz Yisrael and the destruction of both Batei Mikdash) that occurred on Tisha b'Av - were 1. Beitar was captured (following the revolt of Bar Kochba, fifty-two years after the Churban of the second Beis Hamikdash), and 2. Turnusrufus (a Roman general) turned Yerushalayim into a plowed field (shortly after the destruction of the second Beis-Hamikdash).
(b)When Av enters - we minimize on Simchah.
(c)The two things that the Tana of our Mishnah forbids during the week of Tisha b'Av are - having a hair-cut (and shaving) and washing one's clothes.
(d)Washing one's clothes (li'Chevod Shabbos) is permitted on Thursday - when Tisha b'Av falls on Friday (because, when it falls earlier in the week, it goes without saying, that everything is permitted afterwards).
9)
(a)The Tana Kama forbids three (additional) things on Erev Tisha b'Av. What are they?
(b)Raban Shimon ben Gamliel requires a change (which will be explained in the Sugya). Which stringency does Rebbi Yehudah add?
(c)What do the Rabanan say?
9)
(a)The Tana Kama forbids three (additional) things on Erev Tisha b'Av - eating two cooked foods, eating meat and drinking wine.
(b)Raban Shimon ben Gamliel requires a change (which will be explained in the Sugya). Rebbi Yehudah adds the obligation of overturning one's bed (and not sleeping on it - as was customary by a mourner in the times of the Gemara).
(c)The Rabanan disagree with him.
10)
(a)Which two Yamim-Tovim does Raban Shimon ben Gamliel describe as the greatest? What did the unmarried girls used to do then?
(b)Why did they all used to wear borrowed dresses?
(c)Why did all the dresses require Tevilah?
(d)What would the girls say to the young men who might be watching them (see Tiferes Yisrael)?
10)
(a)Raban Shimon ben Gamliel describes Yom Kippur and Chamishah-Asar b'Av as the greatest Yamim-Tovim. On them, he says, the unmarried girls would go out to the vineyards and dance.
(b)They would all wear borrowed dresses - so as not to embarrass the poor girls, who could not afford to buy nice dresses.
(c)All the dresses required Tevilah - since one girl did not know for certain that the girl from whom she borrowed was Tahor.
(d)The girls would say to the young men who might be watching them (see Tiferes Yisrael) - 'See what you are choosing. Don't look for beauty, look at the family! "Sheker ha'Chen ... Ishah Yiras Hash-m Hi Tis'halal" (Mishlei). "Tenu Lah mi'Pri Yadehah ... " (Shir ha'Shirim).
11)
(a)Much of this is hinted in the Pasuk in Shir ha'Shirim "Tze'enah u'Re'enah Benos Tziyon ba'Melech Shlomo ... ". Who is referred to as "Melech Shlomo"?
(b)The Pasuk there concludes "b'Yom Chasunaso u've'Yom Simchas Libo". What is meant by ...
1. ... "b'Yom Chasunaso"?
2. ... "uve'Yom Simchas Libo"?
(c)What then, is the connection between this Pasuk and the previous section of the Mishnah, which speaks about Yom Kippur and Chamishah-Asar b'Av?
11)
(a)Much of this is hinted in the Pasuk in Shir ha'Shirim "Tze'enah u'Re'enah Bnos Tziyon ba'Melech Shlomo ... " - with reference to Hash-m ('to whom peace belongs').
(b)The Pasuk there concludes "b'Yom Chasunaso uve'Yom Simchas Libo". When the Pasuk writes ...
1. ... "b'Yom Chasunaso" - it is referring to the day on which the Torah was given.
2. ... "u've'Yom Simchas Libo" - it is referring to the day of the building of the Beis Hamikdash.
(c)"b'Yom Chasunaso", the day on which the Torah was given - refers (not to Shavu'os but) to Yom Kippur, on which the second Luchos (which remained with Yisrael) were given to Klal Yisrael. Consequently, the connection between this Pasuk and the previous section of the Mishnah, which speaks about Yom Kippur and Chamishah-Asar b'Av is self-evident (even more so according to the Bartenura, who points out that the [first] Beis Hamikdash too, was inaugurated on Yom Kippur).
12)
(a)Our Mishnah lists three occasions in the year on which the Kohanim would Duchen four times. Since when does one recite Musaf on a Ta'anis or on a day of Ma'amados?
12)
(a)Our Mishnah lists three occasions in the year, on which the Kohanim would Duchen four times. This statement has been misquoted, since one does not one recite Musaf on a Ta'anis or on a day of Ma'amados. There are words missing in the Mishnah - and what the Mishnah really means to say is that on three occasions in the year, the Kohanim would Duchen whenever they Davened (normally, three times), but on one of them (i.e. Yom Kippur) they even Duchened four times .
13)
(a)The author of our Mishnah (which requires Kohanim to Duchen both at Minchah of a fast-day and at Ne'ilah), says Rav Nachman quoting Rabah bar Avuha, is Rebbi Meir. But according to the Chachamim, they do not Duchen at either of them. Presuming that the reason that the Kohanim do not Duchen at Minchah is because they have often drunk wine, how will we explain their Machlokes?
(b)Rebbi Yosi has a third opinion. What does he say?
(c)Rav Yehudah quoting Rav, Rebbi Yochanan and Rava all rule like Rebbi Meir (but in varying degrees). What is the meaning of ...
1. ... Halachah k'Rebbi Meir (Rav)?
2. ... Minhag k'Rebbi Meir (Rava)?
3. ... Nahagu k'Rebbi Meir (Rebbi Yochanan)?
(d)We finally conclude like Rav Nachman. Like whom does he rule?
13)
(a)The author of our Mishnah (which requires Kohanim to Duchen both at Minchah of a fast-day and at Ne'ilah), says Rav Nachman quoting Rabah bar Avuha, is Rebbi Meir. But according to the Chachamim (Rebbi Yehudah), they do not Duchen at either of them. Presuming that the reason that there is no Duchening at Minchah throughout the year is because the Kohanim may have drunk wine - Rebbi Meir holds that seeing as this does not apply on a fast-day, there is no reason for them not to Duchen; whereas the Chachamim decree a fast-day on account of the rest of the year.
(b)Rebbi Yosi holds - that they do not Duchen at Minchah on a fast-day, because he decrees Minchah of a fast-day (like the Chachamim), but they do Duchen at Ne'ilah, because, seeing as there is no Ne'ilah during the year, there is nothing to decree.
(c)Rav Yehudah quoting Rav, Rebbi Yochanan and Rava all rule like Rebbi Meir (but in varying degrees).
1. ... Halachah k'Rebbi Meir (Rav) means - that we even Darshen publicly at the Derashah that the Halachah is like Rebbi Meir.
2. ... Minhag k'Rebbi Meir (Rava) - that we will inform anyone who comes to ask, that the Halachah is like Rebbi Meir, but we will not go so far as to Darshen it publicly.
3. ... Nahagu k'Rebbi Meir (Rebbi Yochanan) means - that if someone follows Rebbi Meir's opinion, we will not force him to retract, though should he come to ask, we will not rule like him.
(d)The Gemara's conclusion however, is like Rav Nachman - who rules like Rebbi Yosi.
14)
(a)Why do the Kohanim Duchen at Minchah of a fast-day nowadays?
(b)What do we learn from the juxtaposition of ...
1. ... Birchas Kohanim to the Parashah of Nazir (in Naso)?
2. ... the word "l'Sharso" to "ul'Varech bi'Shemo"(in Ekev)?
(c)From where do we then learn that a Kohen who has a blemish is not invalidated from Birchas Kohanim?
(d)On what grounds do we Darshen these Pesukim leniently (to permit a Kohen who has eaten grapes and a Kohen who has a blemish to Duchen, from a Kohen who performs the Avodah and from a Nazir respectively), and not stringently (to forbid a Kohen who has eaten grapes from a Nazir, and one who has a blemish from a Kohen who performs the Avodah)?
14)
(a)The reason that Kohanim Duchen at Minchah of a fast-day nowadays is - because, since we tend to Daven Minchah late, it is like Ne'ilah (at which the Kohanim Duchen - according to Rebbi Yosi). Note, that this is not the Minhag today.
(b)We learn from the juxtaposition of ...
1. ... Birchas Kohanim to the Parashah of Nazir - that before Duchening, a Kohen, like a Nazir, is forbidden to drink wine.
2. ... the word "l'Sharso" to "ul'Varech bi'Shemo" - that he is however, permitted to eat grapes before Duchening, just as he is permitted to do before performing the Avodah.
(c)We nevertheless learn that a Kohen who has a blemish is not invalidated from Birchas Kohanim - from the juxtaposition of Birchas Kohanim to Nazir.
(d)We Darshen these Pesukim leniently (to permit a Kohen who has eaten grapes and a Kohen who has a blemish to Duchen, from a Kohen who performs the Avodah and from a Nazir respectively), and not stringently (to forbid a Kohen who has eaten grapes [from a Nazir], and one who has a blemish [from a Kohen who performs the Avodah]) - on the grounds that the main Halachah (prohibiting a Kohen to drink wine before Duchening) is really Asur mid'Rabanan, and the Derashah from the Juxtaposition next to Nazir is only an Asmachta.