More Discussions for this daf
1. Hitting an Eved 2. Avid Inish Dinei l'Nafshei 3. Taking the law into one's own hands
4. Shor she'Alah Al Gabei Chaveiro 5. Shor she'Alah Al Gabei Chaveiro 6. Rav's Opinion
7. Shor she'Alah Al Gabei Chaveiro 8. Bava Kama 028: Shor she'Alah Al Gabei Chaveiro (continued) 9. Tosafos d"h Hani Mili
DAF DISCUSSIONS - BAVA KAMA 28

David sadovitch asks:

In Rav´s opinion, if it's not made heffker is going to be liable for kelim so how is he going to make the guy who threw the Keli and damaged liable (throwing somthing at a stone surely is considered as hefker)

David sadovitch, Mexico City Mexico

The Kollel replies:

1) The Rambam (Hilchos Chovel u'Mazik 6:10) writes that if someone threw a stone and it caused damage, this is equivalent to damaging directly with one's hands and is in the category of "Adam ha'Mazik."

2) Throwing a stone at a person or at property is the same as hitting him directly, because it comes from the "Ko'ach," the strength, of the thrower.

3) When a person throws a stone, it is not the stone that damages; it is the person who throws it. "Adam" -- the Man who damages -- is a very different category of damages than the Bor (pit) mentioned on 28a-28b.

Dovid Bloom