1)
(a)Rav Yosef quotes a Beraisa which explains the Pasuk in Yisro "ve'Hoda'ata Lahem es ha'Derech Asher Yeilchu bah ve'es ha'Ma'aseh Asher Ya'asun" - "ve'Hoda'ata Lahem", 'Zeh Beis Chayeihem'. What does 'Beis Chayeihem' refer to?
(b)The Tana learns from "es ha'Derech", 'Zu Gemilus Chasadim'. What does he learn from ...
1. ... "Yeilchu"?
2. ... "bah"?
(c)And he learns from "ve'es ha'Ma'aseh", 'Zeh ha'Din'. What does he learn from "Asher Ya'asun"?
(d)Having taught Gemilus Chasadim, why did Yisro find it necessary to add ...
1. ... Bikur Cholim?
2. ... Kevurah?
1)
(a)Rav Yosef quotes a Beraisa which explains the Pasuk in Yisro "ve'Hoda'ata Lahem es ha'Derech Asher Yeilchu bah ve'es ha'Ma'aseh Asher Ya'asun". "ve'Hoda'ata Lahem", 'Zeh Beis Chayeihem' i.e. Torah-study (or earning one's livelihood).
(b)The Tana learns from "es ha'Derech", the Mitzvah of Gemilus Chasadim', from ...
1. ... "Yeilchu" that of Bikur Cholim, and ...
2. ... from "bah" that of burial.
(c)He learns from "ve'es ha'Ma'aseh", 'Zeh ha'Din', and from "Asher Ya'asun" the Mitzvah of going 'li'Fenim mi'Shuras ha'Din'.
(d)Having taught Gemilus Chasadim, Yisro nevertheless found it necessary to add ...
1. ... Bikur Cholim, to teach us that even a ben Gil (someone born under the same Mazal, who takes one sixtieth of the patient's illness) is obligated to perform it.
2. ... Kevurah, to teach us that even an elder, who is exempt from acts of kindness which are below his dignity that pertain to the living, is obligated to perform it.
2)
(a)What did Reish Lakish say to Rebbi Elazar (who was a banker - see Tosfos DH 'Achvi Dinar') when he gave him a coin to examine?
(b)Rebbi Elazar cited Reish Lakish himself who connected this with Rebbi Meir. To which Halachah of Rebbi Meir was he referring?
(c)On what grounds did Rebbi Elazar query Reish Lakish?
(d)What did Reish Lakish reply?
2)
(a)When Resh Lakish handed Rebbi Elazar (who was a banker see Tosfos DH 'Achvi Dinar') a coin to examine, he said 'See, I am relying on you'.
(b)Rebbi Elazar cited Resh Lakish himself who connected this with Rebbi Meir's 'Dina d'Garmi'.
(c)He queried Resh Lakish on the grounds that his statement 'Rebbi Meir Hu de'Da'in Diyna d'Garmi' implies that this is Rebbi Meir's individual opinion, but that he himself does not abide by it.
(d)Resh Lakish replied that in this case, he both quoted Rebbi Meir and held like him.
3)
(a)What does Rebbi Meir say about a Dayan who vindicates the guilty party, obligates the innocent party, declares Tamei what is Tahor or Tahor what is Tamei?
(b)This Mishnah cannot be Rebbi Meir's source for 'Dina de'Garmi', because of Rebbi Ila'a Amar Rav's interpretation. What did Rebbi Ila'a Amar Rav say?
(c)How does 'Nasa ve'Nasan be'Yad apply to the case of ...
1. ... 'Zikah es ha'Chayav'?
2. ... 'Chiyev es ha'Zakai'?
3. ... 'Timei es ha'Tahor'?
4. ... 'Tiher es ha'Tamei'?
3)
(a)Rebbi Meir says that if a Dayan vindicates the guilty party, obligates the innocent party, declares Tamei what is Tahor or Tahor what is Tamei what he did is done, but he is Chayav to pay.
(b)This Mishnah cannot be Rebbi Meir's source for 'Dina d'Garmi', because of Rebbi Ila'a Amar Rav, who establishes Rebbi Meir where the Dayan actually did the damage with his hands (Nasa ve'Nasan be'Yad), whereas we are speaking specifically about verbal damage.
(c)'Nasa ve'Nasan be'Yad applies to the case of ...
1. ... 'Zikah es ha'Chayav' there where he takes the security from the creditor and returns it to the debtor.
2. ... 'Chiyev es ha'Zakai' where he takes money from the debtor and hands it to the creditor.
3. ... 'Timei es ha'Tahor' where he takes a Sheretz and throws it on the Taharos, to demonstrate that it really is Tamei (even though in fact, it was not).
4. ... 'Tiher es ha'Tamei' where he picked up the Tamei fruit, and (in order to demonstrate that they are really Tahor [even though, in fact, they are not]), he mixes them with other Tahor fruit belonging to the same owner.
4)
(a)What does Rebbi Meir rule in the Mishnah ...
1. ... later on the Daf ' ... li'Tzevo'a lo Adom, ve'Tzav'o Shachor, Shachor, ve'Tzav'o Adom'?
2. ... in Kil'ayim 'ha'Mesachech Gafno al-Gabei Tevu'aso shel Chaveiro'?
(b)Why can neither of these Mishnayos be Rebbi Meir's source for Diyna de'Garmi'?
4)
(a)According to Rebbi Meir in the Mishnah ...
1. ... later on the Daf ' ... li'Tzevo'a lo Adom, ve'Tzav'o Shachor, Shachor, ve'Tzav'o Adom' the dyer must pay the owner for his wool.
2. ... in the Mishnah in Kil'ayim 'ha'Mesachech Gafno al-Gabei Tevu'aso shel Chaveiro' both are forbidden and the Mazik is obligated to pay.
(b)Neither of these Mishnayos can be Rebbi Meir's source for Diyna d'Garmi' because in both cases, the Mazik performed the damage with his hands, as we explained with regard to the Mishnah 'Dan es ha'Din ... '.
5)
(a)His source for 'Dina d'Garmi' is actually a Beraisa. If the partition wall dividing between his vines and his neighbor's crops became breached, what does the Tana quote the latter as saying to the former (see Tosfos DH 'Omer Lo G'dor')?
(b)At which stage will both the vines and the crops become Kilayim?
(c)Rebbi Meir rules that if the owner of the vineyard fails to respond to the two warnings, both become forbidden. What does he add, proving that he holds 'Dina d'Garmi'?
5)
(a)His source for 'Dina d'Garmi' is actually a Beraisa, where, in the case where the partition wall dividing between his vines and his neighbor's crops became breached the Tana quotes the latter as requesting the former (see Tosfos DH 'Omer Lo Gedor') to repair the breach, and, should the breach occur again, as repeating the request.
(b)Both the vines and the crops become Kilayim if the crops increase by one two hundredth (before he begins to repair the breach).
(c)Rebbi Meir rules that if the owner of the vineyard fails to respond to the two warnings, both become forbidden and the Mazik is Chayav to pay, proving conclusively that he holds 'Dina d'Garmi'.
100b----------------------------------------100b
6)
(a)Our Mishnah rules that if a dyer burns the wool that he has been given to dye, he must pay for the wool. Why does the Tana not obligate him to pay the Shevach, like he does in the following case?
(b)If he succeeded in dyeing the wool, but made a poor job of it, under which circumstances does the owner pay the dyer ...
1. ... his expenses?
2. ... the Shevach (the amount that the wool increased in value due to the dyeing)?
(c)Why does the dyer not pay the owner for his wool, like he did in the previous case?
6)
(a)Our Mishnah rules that if a dyer burns the wool that he has been given to dye, he must pay for the wool. The Tana does not obligate him to pay the Shevach, like he does in the following case because the Tana is speaking where the wool burned immediately, in which case there is no Shevach (as we learned earlier in the Perek).
(b)If he succeeded in dyeing the wool, but made a poor job of it, the owner pays the dyer ...
1. ... his expenses if they amount to less than the Shevach (the amount that the wool increased in value due to the dyeing).
2. ... the Shevach if it amounts to less than the dyer's expenses.
(c)The dyer does not pay the owner for his wool, like he did in the previous case because, on account of the fact that the dyer did not deviate from his instructions, there is no Shinuy, in which case there is no reason for him to acquire the wool.
7)
(a)According to Rebbi Meir, if the owner gives the dyer the wool in order to dye it red and he dyes it black, or vice-versa, the dyer pays for the wool, as we have already learned a number of times. Why is that?
(b)What does Rebbi Yehudah say?
(c)Seeing as Rebbi Yehudah too, agrees that Shinuy is Koneh, on what basis does he argue with Rebbi Meir?
7)
(a)According to Rebbi Meir, if the owner gives the dyer the wool in order to dye it red and he dyes it black or vice-versa, the dyer pays for the wool, as we have already learned a number of times because he is Koneh it with Shinuy.
(b)Rebbi Yehudah says that the owner takes his wool and pays for whichever is less of the Shevach or the expenses.
(c)Despite the fact that Rebbi Yehudah too, agrees that Shinuy is Koneh, he nevertheless argues with Rebbi Meir on the basis of a Knas which, he maintains, Chazal imposed on the dyer (for deviating from his instructions), denying him the possibility of deriving benefit from the improvement.
8)
(a)We learned in our Mishnah that, if the dyer made a poor job of the dyeing, then he pays the lesser of the improvement of the wool and the dyer's expenses. Rav Nachman Amar Rabah bar Shmuel explains the Lashon 'Tzav'o Ka'ur' to mean Kalbus, which the latter then explains as 'Kafra Dudi'. What does 'Kufra Dudi' mean?
8)
(a)We learned in our Mishnah that, if the dyer made a poor job of the dyeing, then he pays the lesser of the improvement of the wool and the dyer's expenses. Rav Nachman Amar Rabah bar Shmuel explains the Lashon 'Tzav'o Ka'ur' to mean Kalbus, which the latter then explains as 'Kafra Dudi' (meaning 'the cleansing of the cauldron', which in turn, refers to the dyes that remain in the cauldron from the previous dyeing [and which the dyer used in this case, to dye the wool]).