Questions: If one vowed from Mevushal, is he permitted smoked food? Is he permitted fried food? Is he permitted food cooked in hot [spring] water of Tiverya?

Questions (Rabanan of Kisarin): Smoked food - does [the Isur of] Bishul Akum (food that Nochrim cooked) apply to it? Is [one liable for smoking food] due to cooking on Shabbos (PRI CHADASH YD 87:2)? Does [the Isur of cooking] meat and milk apply to it? Does smoking food make it Tevel (forbid eating it Arai before separating) Ma'aseros (like cooking does)?

Question (Rabanan of Kisarin): If one vowed from smoked food - is he permitted a Tavshil? (MEICHAL HA'MAYIM - surely 'smoked' does not include cooked! Rather, we ask about a smoked food that was later cooked, or a Tavshil that was later smoked.)

(R. Ba bar Yehudah citing Beis Rav Achi): Chavitza (a congealed dish of flour, oil and honey - PNEI MOSHE) Bishul Akum does not apply to it (presumably, this is like Rav Yehudah (Bavli Brachos 36b), who says that the honey is primary, so it is considered something eaten raw - PF), and one may use it for Eruvei Tavshilin (it is called a cooked food);

(R. Yosi bei R. Bun citing R. Chunah): Anything that is eaten raw, like it is, [the Isur of] Bishul Akum does not apply to it, and one is Yotzei through it for Eruvei Tavshilin (if it was cooked, even via a Nochri).

Question: If one vowed from Mevushal, is he permitted Avah (a thick Tavshil)?

Answer #1: We learn from [our Mishnah. If one vowed from Tavshil,] He is forbidden soft things made in a pot, and permitted Avah;

If [one vowed from] Tavshil, he is forbidden roasted and Shaluk, and he is permitted Avah - [if one vowed from] Mevushal, he is permitted roasted and Shaluk, all the more so he should be permitted Avah!

Rebuttal: Is there a Kal v'Chomer in Nedarim?! (It depends on Leshon Bnei Adam!)

Answer #2: Rather, [if one vowed from] Tavshil, he is forbidden roasted and Shaluk, and he is permitted Avah. [If one vowed from] Mevushal, he is permitted roasted and Shaluk, and he is permitted Avah. (This is not a Kal v'Chomer. Rather, Mevushal is only what was cooked in water.)

(Beraisa): [If one vowed from Tavshil,] he is forbidden soft gourds, for a doctor often [commands a Choleh] to eat his bread with them.

(Rav Chisda): He is forbidden a roasted egg, for a doctor often [commands a Choleh] to eat his bread with it.

[Our Mishnah says that] he is permitted a Tarmitan egg - it was boiled very much.

[Our Mishnah says that] he is permitted a Remutzah gourd - Rav Chisda said, this is a kind of bitter gourd, and they sweeten it with hot ashes.