Chart for Gitin Daf 84b-85a

IF A 'GET' IS GIVEN WITH A WRITTEN OR ORAL EXCEPTION, WILL IT TAKE EFFECT?

(A)

RAV SAFRA &

RAV ZEIRA

(B)

RAVA

1) WROTE 'EXCEPT FOR PLONI' Not Valid Not Valid
2) SAID 'EXCEPT FOR PLONI' Valid

Before Toref: Not valid

After Toref: Valid

3) WROTE 'ON CONDITION THAT SHE DOESN'T MARRY PLONI'

Before Toref: Valid
(but Rebbi says not valid)

After Toref: Valid

Before Toref: Not valid

After Toref: Valid
(but Rebbi says not valid)

4) SAID 'ON CONDITION THAT SHE DOESN'T MARRY PLONI' Valid

Before Toref: Not valid

After Toref: Valid

-------------------------------------------------
-------------------------------------------------