More Discussions for this daf
1. Shevuah for Hekdesh 2. Is 'Ona'as Devarim' another name for 'Boshes'? 3. Hiring a Day Laborer to Watch the Parah Adumah
4. concluding statement of Kol Davar ha'Masur la'Lev... 5. Olam ha'Ba and Gehenom 6. המוכר ספר תורה אין לה אונאה
7. רש"י במלחמה 8. שומר חנם אינו נשבע

Mark Bergman asked:

On 58a the Gemoro presents an answer of Rabba, then an answer of Reb Yochanan, then rejects the answer of Reb Yochanan and says "Ella Omar Reb Elozar...".

I presume that the "Ella..." is just rejecting the answer of Reb Yochanan, but the answer of Rabba is still valid. Do you agree?

Kol Tuv

Mark Bergman

Manchester UK

The Kollel replies:

Agreed. However, according to Rabah the Shevuah is not actually on the Shemirah; rather it is in order to collect his wage. According to Reb Elazar, on the other hand, if they don't swear they will actually be liable as a Shomer.

D. Zupnik