More Discussions for this daf
1. Is a wick a keli? 2. Rashi's and Rashba's explanation of the Gemara 3. Being Metaher a Wick According to Rebbi Akiva
4. Animal Hides Fit for STaM 5. Tum'ah on Behemah Teme'ah 6. Wick from a Beged
7. טומאת מאהיל
DAF DISCUSSIONS - SHABBOS 28

gabriel shagabayev asks:

why is it relevant for the mishnah to tell that the wick is 3 by 3 exactly.

gabriel shagabayev, brooklyn

The Kollel replies:

Dear Gabriel,

If the wick is exactly 3 by 3, lighting the wick is now causing a broken Kli, which is Muktzah, and therefore he is not allowed to continue to hold the fire to the now broken Kli/wick.

In the Mesivta Hebrew edition of the Gemara, note 45, there is a comment which admits that even if the wick is originally slightly larger than 3 by 3 the same situation exists, since the lighting of the wick will shorten it to under 3 by 3, and therefore "exactly" 3 by 3 is Lav Davka (imprecise).

All the best,

Reuven Weiner