DAF DISCUSSIONS - GITIN 17

Alex Benedyk asks:

The gemara answers a question with(eipuch) - that actually reish lakish holds the husband gets the perot until the get is written. My question here is didn't we establish Reish Lakish holds this is a machloket between the Rabbis and Rebbi Shimon on whether it is until the writing or signing? Therefore, what is the use of switching his answer around...surely he holds both? Thanks

Alex Benedyk, UK

The Kollel replies:

We would expect that Reish Lakish would Paskan like the Chachamim, which is true if we switch around what he said.

Sorry for the delay in answering.

Dov Freedman