Shabos21, INSIGHTS INTO THE DAILY DAF, 2) USING BAD WICKS OR OILS FOR THE CHANUKAH LIGHTS
You say :
ANSWERS:(b) The RASHBA explains that in truth we cannot infer from Rav Huna's statement that he permits the use of the Chanukah lights. Nevertheless, the Gemara says that according to Rav Huna one is permitted to use the Chanukah lights because it assumes that Rav Huna probably agrees with his Rebbi, Rav Chisda, who clearly says that one is permitted to use the Chanukah lights.
You say that Rav Chisda was the rebi of Rav Huna. But it is the contrary : Rav Huna was the Rebi of Rav Chisda ?
Am i wrong ?
KOL TOV
Aralé, FRANCE
Yes you are right, as Rashi writes in Gitin 7a (DH Rav Chisda), that Rav Chisda was a Talmid of Rav Huna. We have corrected it in the Insights to read:
>>
(b) The RASHBA explains that in truth we cannot infer from Rav Huna's statement that he permits the use of the Chanukah lights. Nevertheless, the Gemara says that according to Rav Huna one is permitted to use the Chanukah lights because it assumes that Rav Huna maintained the view which his student, Rav Chisda, expressed explicitly, that one is permitted to use the Chanukah lights.
<<
Kol Tuv,
Dovid`Bloom