More Discussions for this daf
1. Rented donkeys and boats 2. Rented donkeys 3. Tosfos
4. Royal Troops Who Commandeer Donkeys 5. Tosfos DH Rebbi Yosi bar Chanina Amar 6.
7. השוכר את החמור והבריקה
DAF DISCUSSIONS - BAVA METZIA 78

Dov Abraham asked:

On page 79:, the gmara says that if a donkey was hired for a man, a woman should not ride it. But in the opposite case, if it was hired for a woman, a man may ride on the donkey.

The Poskim give the reason that a woman is more heavy.

But reality shows the opposite. On the average, men weigh more.

Can we give a different reason - the quality of a woman driver?

Dov Abraham

Petach Tikva

Israel

The Kollel replies:

Since women ride side-saddle, they weigh down more on the donkey (requiring the donkey to exert more effort in balancing, moving, etc.).

D. Zupnik

Shmuel D Berkovicz comments:

The Chasdei David says like Dov Abraham suggested.

Shmuel Berkovicz