Aryeh Berkley asked:
In the sugya of Keren Keiyn shegonav the tosfos Rid offers a very mechudash peshat which i understand but can not create any sevora for i was wondering if you knew of any.He compared Kefel of Genaiva to Keren of Gezaila is there a sevora
Kol Tuv
Aryeh
London England
The Kollel replies:
According to the Tosfos Rid, we are discussing a case in which the Geneivah still exists. Therefore, without the verse of "Chayim Yeshalem," the Ganav would say "Harei Shelcha l'Faneicha" as the Gazlan does. However, as far as the Keren of the Ganav goes, there is a Ribuy from "Chayim" for Keren k'Ein she'Gganav.
The Tosfos Rid is basically a Shitas Yachid in the Rishonim, and his approach is a Chidush.
D. Zupnik