More Discussions for this daf
1. Yibum she'Lo k'Darkah 2. Rashi's quotation of the verse 3. Ha'ara'ah
4. Ha'arah Min ha'Torah 5. Bi'ah Shelo k'Darkah 6. Intent for Yibum
7. למה לי למכתבא באחות אב למה לי למכתבא באחות אם 8. אחות אביו מן האם או דוקא מן האב
DAF DISCUSSIONS - YEVAMOS 54

Mark Bergman asked:

The Gemoro on daf 54a attempts to find a mekor for Haaroh for all aroyos, and tries three pesukim, but is unable to learn all aroyos from any of the three. The Gemoro then tries different pairs of pesukim, but is still unable to learn all aroyos from any pair.

My question is could the Gemoro not have learned from all three together?

The Kollel replies:

The Gemara was relying on the final refutation -- Eishes Ish -- which both has a Heter and has the added leniency that the cause of the Isur (i.e. the husband) is the Matir which therefore could not be learned even from all three.

Dov Zupnik