Bava Metzia Chart #7
Chart for Bava Metzia Daf 23a
WHAT ARE REBBI YEHUDAH AND THE TANA KAMA
ARGUING ABOUT IN THE MISHNAH (21a) IN THE CASE OF
ONE WHO FINDS A LOAF OF BREAD WITH COINS INSIDE OF IT?
| (A) IS A "SIMAN HA'BA ME'ELAV" A VALID SIMAN? |
(B) IS A "SIMAN HE'ASUY LI'DARES" A VALID SIMAN? |
(C) IS IT PERMITTED TO BE "MA'AVIRIN AL HA'OCHLIN?" |
||
| 1 | THE HAVAH AMINA, ACCORDING TO THE FIRST LASHON |
Yes | Machlokes | Yes (1) |
| 2 | THE HAVAH AMINA, ACCORDING TO THE SECOND LASHON |
Yes | No | Machlokes |
| 3 | THE CONCLUSION, ACCORDING TO RAVA (BOTH LESHONOS) |
Machlokes | Yes | Yes (1) |
| 4 | THE CONCLUSION, ACCORDING TO RABAH (BOTH LESHONOS) | Machlokes | No | No |
-------------------------------------------------