More Discussions for this daf
1. Kinyan ha'Guf 2. Kinyan Peiros K'kinyan ha'Guf 3. Question on the Logic of the Gemara
4. Idis Or Ziburis 5. Sdeh Achuzah-Question on Quiz
DAF DISCUSSIONS - GITIN 48

Yossi Klein asks:

>>4. A firstborn receives a double portion in a field that returns to his father in Yovel.

a) True.

b) False.

c) Only if sold specifically for the fruits.

d) Machlokes A&B.

e) Machlokes A&C.

Correct answer: (a)<<

By saying that this supports shita of Reish Lakish implication is that Rav Yochanan wouldn't agree therefore should be machlokes

Kol tuv

Yossi

The Kollel replies:

Yossi,

You are absolutely right and I will ask the Kollel to make the change on the website

Shimon Brodie