Pesachim Chart #13
Chart for Pesachim Daf 84b
WHEN IS IT FORBIDDEN OR PERMITTED
TO BREAK A BONE OF THE KORBAN PESACH
| (A) RABANAN "*BO* V'LO " B'PASUL |
(B) REBBI "YE'ACHEL... LO TISHBERU" |
(C) REBBI & THE RABANAN, ACCORDING TO THE OTHER AMORA'IM |
||
| 1 | REBBI YIRMEYAH: PESACH HA'BA B'TUM'AH |
Mutar | Asur | Mutar |
| 2 | *RAV YOSEF: HAYESAH LO SHE'AS HA'KOSHER(1) |
Asur | Mutar | Mutar |
| 3 | *ABAYE: MIB'OD YOM |
Asur | Mutar | Asur |
| 4 | RAV PAPA: EVER SHE'YATZA MIKTZASO |
Asur | Mutar | Mutar |
| 5 | RAV SHESHES BREI D'RAV IDI: NA(2) |
Asur | Mutar | Asur |
| 6 | *RAV NACHMAN BAR YITZCHAK: ETZEM HA'ALYAH |
Asur | Mutar | Mutar |
| 7 | (*)RAV ASHI: ETZEM SH'EIN ALAV K'ZAYIS |
Asur | Mutar | Mutar |
| 8 | (*)RAVINA: ETZEM SH'EIN ALAV K'ZAYIS B'MAKOM ZEH V'YESH LO B'MAKOM ACHER |
Asur | Mutar | (4) |
-------------------------------------------------
==========
FOOTNOTES:
==========
* This opinion of the Machlokes between Rebbi and the Rabanan is confirmed by a Beraisa.
(*) The Beraisa refers to one of these two opinions (#7, #8) and confirms that the Machlokes between Rebbi and the Rabanan apply in this case as well. However, it is not clear which one of these two opinions the Beraisa means.