Nidah Chart #1
Chart for Nidah Daf 5a
WHAT IS THE STATUS OF THE WOMAN WHO FINDS DAM
| (A) CHACHAMIM (1) |
(B) REBBI MEIR |
(C) REBBI DOSA (2) |
||
| A WOMAN WITH A VESES (3) |
||||
| 1a) | FINDS BLOOD DURING BEDIKAH | me'Es l'Es (4) | --- | From now on |
| 1b) | FINDS A STAIN | me'Es l'Es | --- | me'Es l'Es |
| THE FOUR WOMEN WHO NORMALLY DO NOT SEE DAM NIDAH |
||||
| 2a) | FINDS BLOOD DURING BEDIKAH | From now on (5) | From now on (5) | From now on (5) |
| 2b) | FINDS A STAIN | --- | me'Es l'Es (6) | From now on (6) |
==========
FOOTNOTES:
==========
(1) The Chachamim who argue with Rebbi Dosa, as recorded in a Beraisa not quoted by the Gemara (Rashi 4b, DH Rebbi Dosa).
(2) Rebbi Dosa, following the view of Rebbi Chanina ben Antignos.
(3) This refers to a case in which the woman found blood at the expected time. If she finds blood earlier or later, then all agree that she is Tamei retroactively, me'Es l'Es.
(4) That is, she is Tamei retroactively 24 hours (with regard to all of the Taharos that she touched).
(5) This is according to Rashi (DH Ha she'Ein). Tosfos (DH Ha), however, seems to understand that that all of the Tana'im quoted by the Gemara maintain that the four women are Tamei retroactively me'Es l'Es (see Rashash).
(6) This applies to all of the cases, except for a girl under the age of twelve who has never seen blood; she is completely Tahor, even if she finds a stain.