Nedarim Chart #9
Chart for Nedarim Daf 68b-69a
THE CASES LISTED IN THE BERAISA OF "NISROKNAH"
| THE FATHER | ||||
| (A) HE DIED BEFORE HEARING NEDER |
(B) HEARD NEDER BUT DID NOT ANNUL OR UPHOLD IT |
(C) HEARD NEDER AND ANNULLED IT |
||
| THE HUSBAND | ||||
| 1) | HE DIED BEFORE HEARING THE NEDER |
Case #1a | Case #2 (if father dies) Case #5 (if Arus dies) |
|
| 2) | HEARD NEDER BUT DID NOT ANNUL OR UPHOLD IT |
Case #1a | ||
| 3) | HEARD NEDER AND ANNULLED IT |
Case #3 (if Arus dies) Case #4 (if father dies) |
Case #1a | |
| 4) | HEARD NEDER AND UPHELD IT |
Case #1b | ||
Chart for Nedarim Daf 68b-69a
HALACHAH: DOES "NISROKNAH" OCCUR IN THE FOLLOWING CASES?
(according to the RAN and most Rishonim)
| (A) THE ARUS DIED |
(B) THE FATHER DIED |
||
| 1 | NEITHER THE FATHER NOR THE ARUS HAD HEARD THE NEDER OR THEY BOTH HEARD THE NEDER, BUT NEITHER ANNULLED OR UPHELD IT OR ONE OF THEM DID NOT HEAR THE NEDER, AND THE OTHER ONE WHO HEARD IT DID NOT ANNUL OR UPHOLD IT |
Yes | No |
| 2 | THE ARUS ANNULLED THE NEDER | Yes | No |
| 3 | THE FATHER ANNULLED THE NEDER | B. Shamai: Yes B. Hillel: No |
No |
| 4 | THE FATHER OR ARUS UPHELD THE NEDER | No | No |