Nazir Chart #3
Chart for Nazir Daf 9a-9b
THE HALACHAH OF ONE WHO PLEDGES TO BRING A
MINCHAH-OFFERING IN AN UNUSUAL MANNER
| (A) CHIZKIYAH |
(B) REBBI YOCHANAN |
||
| MINCHAH "MIN HA'SE'ORIM" | |||
| 1a | BEIS HILLEL | Lashon#1: Patur (1)Lashon#2: Chayav (2) |
Chayav (2) |
| 1b | BEIS SHAMAI | Chayav | Chayav (2) |
| MINCHAH "MIN HA'ADASHIM" | |||
| 2a | BEIS HILLEL | Patur | Patur |
| 2b | BEIS SHAMAI | Lashon#1: Chayav (1)Lashon#2: Patur |
Patur |
-------------------------------------------------
==========
FOOTNOTES:
==========
(1) The second version of Chizkiyah follows the same logic as Rebbi Yochanan.
(2) This applies only where he says, "Had I known that the Minchah offering cannot be brought from barley (Se'orim), I would have pledged to bring it from wheat (Chitim)." (See Insights to 9:2:a.)