1)

What is the significance of the juxtaposition of the death of the sons of Aharon to ?ha?Teme?ah? - the last word in Metzora?

1.

R. Bachye: To teach us that, despite the six reasons given by the Chachamim as to why Nadav and Avihu died, 1 they died because they entered the Mikdash be?Tum?ah ? without first washing their hande and feet. 2 3

2.

Moshav Zekenim: Just like a Nidah counts seven days and then [Tovels and] becomes Tahor, so do they separate the Kohen Gadol from his house (and wife) seven days before Yom Kipur. 4


1

Refer to 10:1:1:1-15 and see R. Bachye here, who elaborates.

2

R. Bachye: As the Torah writes in S?mos 30:21 ?Verachatzu Yedeihem Veragleihem ve?Lo Yamusu?.

3

See also Ba?al ha?Turim who gives two other exlanations.

4

In case she sees blood during intimacy, thereby rendering him Tamei for seven days.

2)

?Vayedaber el Moshe Acharei Mos Sh?nei B?nei Aharon?. When was this Parshah said?

1.

Ramban #1: The prohibiton against drinking wine was ssaid to Aharon and the current prohibition to Moshe the day after Nadav and Avihu died ? since on the day that they actually died Aharon was an Onein and an Onein is not subject to Ru?ach ha?Kodesh. And the reason that the current Pasuk is only recorded here is because Hashem opted to give precedence to teaching Yisrael the various Tum?os whih render them Chayav Miysah if they enter the Mishkan be?Tum?ah.

2.

Ramban #2: It was said immidately following the death of Nadav and Avihu. 1


1

Refer to answer ! and see Ramban.

3)

What is the significance of the words "Acharei Mos Sh'nei B'nei Aharon"?

1.

Rashi: To reinforce the warning 1 that Aharon 2 should not enter the Kodesh Kodashim, since his sons had died for entering an area in a way that they should not have done. 3 This can be compared to Reuven who contravened his doctor's instructions not to eat cold food or to sleep in a damp place, and he died. When the doctor issued Shimon with the same instructions, he added 'so that you should not die like Reuven died!'


1

In Pasuk 2.

2

Refer to 16:32:1:1.

3

Refer to 16:1:2:1.

4)

"Acharei Mos Sh'nei B'nei Aharon". Does this mean that Nadav and Avihu died because they entered the Kodesh Kodashim?

1.

Ramban #1: It means that Nadav and Avihu died because they entered the Mishkan in a way that they were not instructed to. 1

2.

R. Bachye #1: The Torah is referring to two separate issues: ?be?Korvasam Lifnei Hashem? refers to Har Sinai, 2 when Nadav and Avihu gazed at the Shechinah - sinning in thought 3 and earning the death penalty; ?Vayamusu?, to their sin in deed which resulted in the death-penalty being carried out ? ?bringing a strange fire? (10:1) ? fire without Ketores. 4

3.

Ibn Ezra: It means that they died because they brought Ketores into the Kodesh Kodashim. 5


1

See Ramban DH ?Aval?.

2

See R. Bachye who proves this from a Midrash Rabah and a Tanchuma.

3

Refer to Sh?mos 24:1:2:1 and note.

4

See R. Chavel?s footnotes.

5

The Ramban in Pasuk 2 objects to this explanation, because Nadav and Avihu would not have been so presumptiou as o eter a locatikon where their had not yet entered.

5)

What are the implications of "ve'Al Yavo be'Chol Eis el ha'Kodesh"?

1.

Rashi (in Pesachim, 95b): It implies that the Kohen Gadol and Kohanim Hedyotos are forbidden to enter the Kodesh or the Kodesh Kodshim without good reason.

2.

R. Bachye: With reference to 16:1:2:2 ? It implies that he should not enter the Kodesh Kodashim without Ketores, like his sons did.

6)

If this was said after Nadav and Avihu died, why was it not taught in Parshas Shemini?

1.

Hadar Zekenim: After the Parshah of Temei'im was taught, the Torah did not give the remedy for one who entered the Mikdash while Tamei. Therefore, this Parshah was taught here - "v'Chiper Al ha'Kodesh" (verse 16).

2.

Moshav Zekenim citing the Rosh: After warning Bnei Yisrael not to die amidst [entering the Mikdash] in their Tum'ah, also Aharon should be warned.

3.

Rosh (3), Moshav Zekenim (citing Vayikra Rabah 20:12): It was written near Avodas Yom Kipur, to teach that the death of Tzadikim atones 1 just like Yom Kipur. 2

4.

Moshav Zekenim #1: People were scorning the Ketores, through which Nadav and Avihu died. Therefore, the verse says that Aharon will come closer than them through Ketores, and he will not die.

5.

Moshav Zekenim #2: They died for entering the Kodesh ha'Kodoshim empty (without Ketores) - "b'Karvasam". Therefore, after mentioning their death, it says "b'Zos Yavo Aharon El ha'Kapores" (verse 3).


1

Rosh: The death of Miryam is written next to Parah Adumah, to teach that just like Efer Parah atones, also death of Tzadikim.

2

Moshav Zekenim: Therefore, it is a good custom to pledge Tzedakah on Yom Kipur to mention the Neshamos of Tzadikim; their merit atones.

7)

Why was this written next to "and one who sleeps with a Temei'ah (Nidah)"?

1.

Moshav Zekenim citing R. Yehudah ha'Chasid: This alludes to Eli's sons, who lied with women 1 and died. Even though only Chafni sinned, it says (Shmuel 1 2:22) "Yishkevun" (plural) because Pinchas could have protested.

2.

Moshav Zekenim (2): Just like a Nidah counts seven days and then [immerses and] becomes Tahor, so they separate the Kohen Gadol from his house (and wife) seven days before Yom Kipur. 2


1

The sin was lying with married women, and not with Nidos! We can say that she is Temei'ah (forbidden) to him. In the conclusion (Shabbos 55b), they merely delayed offering the women's birds, they detained them from returning to their husbands; the verse calls this lying with them. (PF)

2

Yoma 6a: The reason is, lest he have Bi'ah with her and she will see blood, and he will be Tamei for seven days due to Bo'el Nidah.

8)

Why does it say twice that they died in front of Hashem (here and 10:2), and once that they died in front of their father (Divrei ha'Yamim 1 24:2)?

1.

Moshav Zekenim: Their death was twice as painful to Hashem as it was to Aharon. 1


1

Rosh (3), Moshav Zekenim, citing Vayikra Rabah 20:12: Aharon's death (Devarim 10:6) is mentioned next to the breaking of the Luchos (10:2), to teach that death of Tzadikim is harsh to Hashem like the breaking of the Luchos - "Yakar (is heavy) b'Einei Hashem [ha'Mavsah la'Chasidav]" (Tehilim 116:15).

QUESTIONS ON RASHI

9)

Rashi writes that "Acharei Mos?" is like a doctor who told a patient [you should not die like Reuven died]. This is not like the opinions that they died for drinking wine before entering the Mishkan, nor for ruling in front of their Rebbe. Here they were liable for entering without need! Also, "b'Karvasam" implies that they were punished for coming close!

1.

Rashi here explains like the other opinions of why they died (refer to 10:1:1:3-11). (PF)

Sefer: Perek: Pasuk:

KIH Logo
D.A.F. Home Page
Sponsorships & DonationsReaders' FeedbackMailing ListsTalmud ArchivesAsk the KollelDafyomi WeblinksDafyomi CalendarOther Yomi calendars