D.A.F.'s Nach section - shmuel i Chapter 12, Pasuk 13

עברית

Sponsors
& Donors Member's
site Talmud by
the Daf Talmud by
Maseches Chumash Nevi'im &
Kesuvim Haftarah
Highlights Yerushalmi Mishnah Halachah Mishnah
Berurah Lectures Orders Dafyomi
Central Kollel Iyun
Hadaf Feedback Ask a
Question

Why did he say "Asher Bechartem Asher She'eltem"?

Malbim: There are two possibilities. (a) The king can be attributed to you, for you chose to have a king; Hashem did not want this. (b) He can be attributed to Hashem, for you asked for a king, but Hashem chose that it will be Sha'ul.

Sefer: Perek: Pasuk:

D.A.F. thanks the following for their significant contributions
towards the development of this section:

Mechon Mamre, for generously providing the
English & Hebrew Biblical texts

The Estate Distribution Fund of the Government of Israel

D.A.F. Home Page

Sponsorships & Donations • Readers' Feedback • Mailing Lists • Talmud Archives • Ask the Kollel • Dafyomi Weblinks • Dafyomi Calendar • Other Yomi calendars

D.A.F. thanks the following for their significant contributions towards the development of this section:

Mechon Mamre, for generously providing the English & Hebrew Biblical texts

The Estate Distribution Fund of the Government of Israel

D.A.F. thanks the following for their significant contributions
towards the development of this section:

Mechon Mamre, for generously providing the
English & Hebrew Biblical texts