More Discussions for this daf
1. Seifa Itztricha Leih 2. Tashlumim for Hezek 3. Tosfos DH v'Chayav b'Achrayuso
4. Tosfos DH Lefichach 5. Nisya'esh Heimenah 6. Chazakah vs. Umdena
7. Rashi on the first Mishnah 8. Hezek Re'iyah 9. First Tosfos
10. Basar b'Chalav 11. Where should the gatehouse be built? 12. Klai ha'Kerem
13. Hezek Re'iyah 14. מחיצת הכרם שנפרצה
DAF DISCUSSIONS - BAVA BASRA 2

1. Soheil Zaman asks:

Lfi the lishna basra that the chiyuv kosel is because hezek riya shmei hezek, why is the tashlumim in regards to this damage to build a wall?

That is, there is hezek being done. So whenevere there is hezek, we have two opinions how the damage is compensated: man d'amar tashlumei damim and man d'amar tashlumei dina.

The Mishna's requirement to build a kosel means they are poskening lfi man d'amar tashlumei mida. Therefore, my question is what is it about hezek riya which necessitates tashlumim to be lfi mida?

Soheil Zaman, United States

2. The Kollel replies:

The question is not how to do Tashlumim for damage. If you say Shmei Hezek, then one is not allowed to cause damage in the first place, and the only option is to build a wall to prevent damage and then the problem does not begin (not because of compensation).

All the best,

Reuven Weiner