More Discussions for this daf
1. Removing bread from an oven on Shabbos 2. The Hand as a Reshus 3. A Nochri is Chayav?
4. Hotza'ah (hand stretched out to another domain) 5. 3B - Hand in another Reshus 6. Lifnei Iver
7. the "K'nas" of the rabbis 8. Peshat in Tosfos 9. Action which will lead to a d'Oraisa transgression
10. What are the circumstances of the second 11. Holding out the Hand 12. הדביק פת בתנור

Michael asks:

Tosafos says the case in the mishna is where the poor man is a goy. I understand that therefore there is no further issue of Lifnei eever lo seeten michshol.

But if the mishna is speaking that the poor man is a goy , then how can the mishna say he is chayav hotzaah (if he does both the akira and hanacha)? He's a goy?

Michael, Baltimore, MD

The Kollel replies:

The Rashba asks your question on Tosfos.

The Tosfos Ha'Rosh already answered the question by adding that when the Mishnah says the Goy is Chayav, it means that if he would have been a Jew he would be Chayav.

All the best,

Yaakov Montrose