More Discussions for this daf
1. Learning Ma'aseh Bereishis, Ma'aseh Merkavah, and Zohar 2. Rashi's definition of the Chomet 3. Arayos Akum, according to the Netziv
4. Tosfos- The Hanging of Haman's Sons 5. Rebbi's Opinion 6. v'Lo b'Ma'aseh Bereishis b'Shenayim
7. Questions we are not supposed to ask
DAF DISCUSSIONS - CHAGIGAH 11

Avrohom Zachariash asks:

My question is regarding all the Shiurei Daf Hayomi taking place this week.

The Mishna says that Ma'aseh Breishis needs to be learned one-on-one. Then the Gemorah describes the ?' ?÷???? and other topics of ???? ?????? - ???? ?????. Seemingly the Shiurei Daf Hayomi should have to stop for these Blatt, that everyone should learn it on their own, as per the directive of the Mishna.

Avrohom Zachariash, Brooklyn NY

The Kollel replies:

Shalom R' Avrohom!

Great to hear from you. Very excellent question!

Potentially, once the material has been written down in Sefarim, there is a relaxation of the classical prohibition to discuss it in public, since the information is out there anyway. According to this, however, it might be appropriate for a Magid Shiur to intentionally not elaborate too much beyond the basic understanding of the words on the page. And when Talmidim want more detail, for example, it might be best to discuss it privately with their Rebbe.

I hope this helps!

Warm regards,

Yishai Rasowsky