More Discussions for this daf
1. The Tzitz in Rome 2. Tzimtzima ha'Malkah 3. Sayif As An Ornament
DAF DISCUSSIONS - SHABBOS 63

mendel wax asks:

the pasuk of lo yisa goy..is only leasid..now there is war..why should future impact halacha now..do we say that bc in the future a chazir will be chozer to be kosher [Medrash Raba Koheles 1:28] that its kosher now?

mendel wax, baltimore md

The Kollel replies:

Sholom Rav,

To begin with, the Medrash Rabah that you quoted cannot be taken literally (in view of the Rambam's principle [which we cite in the 'Ani Ma'amins'] - that the Torah will never be changed).

But even assuming that it is, the two issues are not comparable - seeing as Chazir nowadays is absolutely forbidden, whereas a world without war is preferable even today. In fact, what the Tana is saying that a sword cannot be considered an ornament, because war is a situation that we would prefer to dispense with - a proof from le'Asid Lavo, when there will be no wars. Consequently, even nowadays it cannot be considered an ornament.

Wishing you a G'mar Chasimah Tovah and Kol Tuv

Eliezer Chrysler