More Discussions for this daf
1. Get Achar Ma'amar 2. Ma'amar Through Zikah 3. רב היה מנגיד - גדרי צניעות
DAF DISCUSSIONS - YEVAMOS 52

Julius Hollander asked:

1) What is the meaning of me'Ikara on 52b

2) What is the proof against Rav Yosef 53a

The Kollel replies:

1)Me'ikara means before the Chalitza and Hashta means after the Chalitza. Even so, according to the Chachamim the Lashon of Ma'amar works equally well both times for Zikah does not assist the Ma'amar in any case.

2) See Tosfos D"H Leima who explains that the Gemara means either or.

Dov Zupnik