More Discussions for this daf
1. Water of the River P'ras 2. Insights to the Daf about praying for the sick 3. Reasons for Bikur Cholim
4. Mats 5. Bikur Cholim
DAF DISCUSSIONS - NEDARIM 40

HG Schild asks:

Rav Chelbo fell ill. There was no one who came to visit him. Rav Kahana said to the Sages: Didn't the incident involving one of the students of Rabbi Akiva who became sick transpire in that manner? In that case, the Sages did not enter to visit him, and Rabbi Akiva entered to visit him and instructed his students to care for him

Why no one? Artscroll said to see sefer SHALMI NEdarim i do not have.

The Kollel replies:

That Sefer is available online (see footnote 1 below).

First, he dismisses one explanation, namely, that the reason the scholars initially refused to visit was because doing so would be beneath their dignity (2).

Instead, he adopts this second explanation: The students of Rebbi Akiva believed that the main obligation of visiting the sick is in order to engage the ill person in coversation. This ill person was suffering from a disease that made speaking difficult. So they argued that it was better not to visit, lest the prospect of conversation aggravate his condition.

Rebbi Akiva, on the other hand, maintained that another central aspect of visiting the sick is to make sure that the place is tidy. That is why Rebbi Akiva ultimately did visit the disciple.

I hope this helps,

Best wishes,

Yishai Rasowsky

Sources:

1. https://hebrewbooks.org/pdfpager.aspx?req=37841&st=&pgnum=65&hilite=

2. As we find such a Heter regarding returning lost objects, as in this link https://www.sefaria.org.il/Bava_Metzia.30b.2?vhe=Wikisource_Talmud_Bavli&lang=bi&with=Tosafot&lang2=en which Rashi also quotes on Chumash at this link https://www.sefaria.org.il/Rashi_on_Exodus.23.5.2?vhe=Pentateuch_with_Rashi%27s_commentary_by_M._Rosenbaum_and_A.M._Silbermann,_1929-1934&lang=bi&with=Exodus&lang2=en