More Discussions for this daf
1. Rebbi Avahu in Caesaria 2. v'Yachid she'Lo Beirach Ein Chaveiro Mevarech Alav 3. 100 Teki'os - and more
4. 100 Teki'os 5. Shema Ya'avirena 6. Error in Background to the Daf
7. One Who Lacks a Shofar 8. Takanah of Chazaras Hashatz 9. 9 Tekios From Yovel to Rosh Ha'Shanah from Hekesh
10. Limud from the Pasuk Tik'u ba'Chodesh 11. אי לאו גזירה שוה מייתינא לה בהיקישא
DAF DISCUSSIONS - ROSH HASHANAH 34

Avrumi Hersh asks:

34a Rashi d"h "ul'sof"

Rashi says: that the reason we could have anyway learned 3x3 teruos from the hekesh, is cos since the posuk says 2 on yom kippur and 1 on rosh hashono, so the teruos of that month are not equal.

(It's mashma from rashi that if there were 2 teruos for rosh hashono, then they would be equal, and we can't learn anything from the hekesh)

So how does rashi explain why we should learn 3 teruos from the hekesh, we should just equalise then to 2 each??

Avrumi Hersh, London england

The Kollel replies:

Dear Avrumi,

Your question is asked by the Tosfos HaRosh DH Hi (he therefore explains the Gemara differently).

Chidushei R' Moshe Imran explains Rashi as follows- the Hekesh cannot be only learning 2 blowings from Rosh HaShana to Yom Kipur Yovel since the other points are learned in the opposite direction, and so there must be a Hekesh adding one blowing learned from Yovel to Rosh HaShana and that makes all together 3.

All the best, Reuven Weiner