More Discussions for this daf
1. Human Ashes? 2. Har Ha'Moriah 3. Additions to Shemoneh Esrei
4. Efer Mikleh 5. Switch in the loshon 6. Who Davens for the Chazan?
7. Can the dead repay favors to the living? 8. Second Beraisa 9. Ninveh and Teshuvah
10. Davening in the town square 11. Is Height an influencing factor? Rashi DH "Adam Shel Tzurah" 12. Shofar on a Ta'anis
DAF DISCUSSIONS - TA'ANIS 16

avrohom adler asked:

In Gevulin the braisa states tiku bnei aharon tiku and the same by teruah. In the Mikdash, the braisa states tiku hakohanim b'nei aharon tiku. Why the switch?

Thank you

avrohom adler, usa

The Kollel replies:

The Girsa of the Munich and other manuscripts have the same text in the Gemara on 16b - which discusses the Mikdash - as appears in the Mishnah: Tik'u ha'Kohanim Tik'u, Hari'u Bnei Aharon Hari'u. (They also change the Girsa earlier on 16b - which discusses Gevulin - to Tik'u ha'Kohanim , rather than Tik'u Bnei Aharon , following the same pattern.) Accordingly, all of the Mishnayos and Beraisos are consistent.

The Gevuras Ari (in the Mishnah 15b) asks why the Mishnah refers to "Kohanim" by the Teki'os and to "Bnei Aharon" by the Teru'os. He has no answer, so he suggests that the Mishnah may simply be saying that either of the appellations may be used for either of the Shofar blowings.

Best wishes,

M. Kornfeld