More Discussions for this daf
1. The Shevu'ah of Shenayim Ochzin 2. Picking up a Metzi'ah 3. Owning all of it
4. Sumchus or the Rabanan 5. Tosfos DH Yachloku 6. Questions in Rashi
7. Case of Mekach U'Memkar 8. Rashi According to Maskanas ha'Gemara 9. Shenayim Ochzin b'Talis
10. Insights to the Daf - Maharam Shif on Rashi 11. "It is all mine" 12. Arguing over a lost object that was found
13. Causing a Shevu'as Shav in our Mishnah 14. Teaching that Re'iyah is not Koneh 15. Two versions
16. Comparing 3/4 Talis oath with devolved oath 17. Acquiring through seeing 18. Terms of Chazakah and ownership
19. בבא מציעא ב. תד"ה בראיה - הבטה בהפקר
DAF DISCUSSIONS - BAVA METZIA 2

Menachem Zaman asks:

Is the safeik that is generated by shnayim ochzin b'talis drara d'mamona?

In the case of shnayim ochzin, do we consider both parties as muchzakos?

In the case of drara d'mamona, are both parties considered muchzakos?

Menachem Zaman, United States

The Kollel replies:

Dear Menachem,

The Gemara (2b, 3 lines from the bottom) says that Shenayim Ochazin is not Derara d'Mamona.

Shenayim Ochazin is called Muchzak since he is holding the Talis.

In the case of the Derara d'Mamona of switching Parah b'Chamor, no one is Muchzak in the Vlad.

All the best,

Reuven Weiner