Beitzah Chart #10
Chart for Beitzah Daf 31a
WHAT TYPE OF WOOD DO
BEIS SHAMAI AND BEIS HILLEL ARGUE ABOUT?
| (A) IN A KARPAF |
(B) IN A FIELD |
||
| 1 | GATHERED WOOD | Mutar (1) | RSB'E: they argue Rav Yehudah: Asur |
| 2 | SCATTERED WOOD | RSB'E: they argue Rav Yehudah: Asur |
Asur |
Chart for Beitzah Daf 31a
FROM WHAT TYPE OF "KARPAF"
MAY ONE BRING IN WOOD ON YOM TOV?
| (A) NEAR THE CITY |
(B) FAR FROM THE CITY |
||
| FIRST SUGGESTION | |||
| 1) | REBBI YEHUDAH | Needs a lock | --- (2) |
| 2) | REBBI YOSI | Needs no lock* | Needs a lock* |
| SECOND SUGGESTION | |||
| 3) | REBBI YEHUDAH | Needs no lock* | --- (2) |
| 4) | REBBI YOSI | Needs a lock | Needs a lock |
-------------------------------------------------
==========
FOOTNOTES:
==========
(1) Apparently, this is the case in which Beis Shamai and Beis Hillel argue according to Rav Yehudah in the name of Shmuel, since he maintains that in all of the other cases they do not argue.
(2) According to Rebbi Yehudah, it is never permitted to bring in wood from a Karpaf that is far from the city.
*This is the conclusion of the Gemara according to Rashi (see Insights). According to Tosfos, the Gemara concludes entirely like the First Suggestion (rows 1 and 2).