Beitzah Chart #3
Chart for Beitzah Daf 10b
BIRDS PREPARED FOR USE ON YOM TOV THAT WERE LOST
AND PURSES CONTAINING COINS OF MA'ASER THAT WERE LOST;
ONLY HALF OF THE SUM OF THE ORIGINAL NUMBER OF
BIRDS AND COINS WERE FOUND
| (A) ACCORDING TO THE OPINION THAT THE MACHLOKES IS IN THE CASE OF ONE PURSE |
(B) ACCORDING TO THE OPINION THAT THE MACHLOKES IS IN THE CASE OF TWO PURSES |
||
| 1 | ALL OF THE COINS ARE IN ONE PURSE |
Coins: Chulin (1) Birds: Muktzah |
Coins: Chulin (1) Birds: Muktzah |
| 2 | THE COINS ARE IN TWO PURSES WHICH ARE TIED TOGETHER, AND THE BIRDS ARE TIED TOGETHER |
Coins: Machlokes (2) Birds: Not Muktzah |
Coins: Chulin Birds: Muktzah |
| 3 | THE COINS ARE IN TWO PURSES WHICH ARE NOT TIED TOGETHER, AND THE BIRDS ARE NOT TIED TOGETHER |
Coins: Ma'aser Birds: Not Muktzah |
Coins: Machlokes (2) Birds: Not Muktzah |
-------------------------------------------------
==========
FOOTNOTES:
==========
(1) The reason is because since first purse was definitely taken, it is assumed that all of the coins were taken along with it, and the coins that are now in its place are not the same coins.
(2) Rebbi and Rabanan argue about this in the Beraisa. Rebbi holds that the remaining coins are Ma'aser (out of doubt). The Rabanan hold that all of the coins are Chulin, for we assume that the Ma'aser was removed and the coins that are there now are other coins that were not Ma'aser.