(Permission is granted to redistribute this material as long as the Kollel header and the subscription info at the end are included.) |
brought to you by Kollel Iyun Hadaf of Har Nof
Rosh Kollel: Rabbi Mordecai Kornfeld
Email - daf@shemayisrael.co.il
_________________________________________________________________
Yoma Chart #7
(A) THE OBLIGATION OF THE TEVILAH |
(B) THE REASON FOR THE TEVILAH |
||
---|---|---|---|
1) | BEN ZOMA | mid'Oraisa | Kal v'Chomer from the Tevilah of the Kohen Gadol when he changes from Bigdei Kodesh to other Bigdei Kodesh |
2) | REBBI YEHUDAH | mid'Rabanan | "Serach Tevilah"(2) |
3) | RABANAN (OF THE MISHNAH IN MIDOS REGARDING THE LISHKAH OF THE METZORA'IM) |
no Chiyuv(3) except for a Metzora on his eighth day |
because he is Tahor |
==========
FOOTNOTES:
==========
(1) This does not mean only in the morning. Rather, it means whenever one
enters the Azarah for the first time that day. Also, he does not necessarily
have to enter to perform an Avodah; entering for any reason warrants Tevilah
(TOSFOS 30a, DH Ein). However, the TOSFOS YESHANIM (30a, DH Amar Rav
Nachman) maintains that Tevilah is only required when one enters to do an
act which is at least *like* an Avodah (such as performing Semichah and
Tenufah, and a Metzora who puts his hands into the Azarah in order for the
Dam to be sprinkled on his thumbs). [He also cites the opinion of RABEINU
YOSEF who says that Tevilah is only required when one enters to do an actual
Avodah -- although he agrees that one who enters even to do an Avodah which
a Zar may perform, such as Shechitah, requires Tevilah.]
(2) This means that we are concerned that he might have become Tamei by
touching a Sheretz or a Tamei Meis and he does not remember, and by
requiring him to do Tevilah he will remember that he was Tamei and he now is
a Tevul Yom and will refrain from doing the Avodah. The practical
consequence of this reason is if he did Tevilah the evening before (before
Sheki'ah), he does not have to do another Tevilah in the morning, since he
is certainly Tahor from all Tum'ah as a result of his Tevilah (we do not
suspect that he became Tamei by touching a Meis and he requires Haza'as
Shlishi v'Shevi'i).
(3) This is because the Metzora is accustomed to being Tamei and touching
Tamei items ("Dayish b'Tum'ah"), and this Tevilah reminds him that he must
stay away from Tamei items. The LECHEM MISHNAH (Hilchos Mechusrei Kaparah
4:1) and other Acharonim understand that a person who is not a Metzora needs
no Tevilah at all (and these Rabanan argue with the Tana of our Mishnah).
However, the CHAFETZ CHAIM (Zevach Todah) writes that these Rabanan
certainly require Tevilah even for someone who is not a Metzora; they
maintain, though, that the Tevilah the night before suffices. The only
difference between the Rabanan and Rebbi Yehudah, according to the Chafetz
Chaim, is that the Rabanan hold that a Metzora needs another Tevilah in the
morning of the eighth day even though he was Tovel the prior evening, and
Rebbi Yehudah holds that he needs no additional Tevilah in the morning.
(However, it is not clear how he will explain the second and third answers
of the Gemara concerning the Mishnah in Midos, which clearly imply that
while Rebbi Yehudah requires a normal person to be Tovel, the Rabanan exempt
him completely, even though the case must be that he was *not* Tovel the
evening before -- since Rebbi Yehudah requires him to be Tovel now, in the
morning.)
Main Yoma Page |
List of Charts and Graphics |
Insights to the Daf |
Background to the Daf |
Review the Daf Questions and Answers |
Point by Point Summary |