According to Rav Nachman one who stuck his hand outside what may he do at this point?
- Nothing,he leaves his hand out all שבת.
- He may just drop it.
- He may bring it back in.
- He may bring it into another חצר .
- Someone else can bring it back in.
One puts bread to bake in an oven on שבת במזיד what if anything can be done to save him from סקילה ?
- Nothing.
- Only he may take it out.
- His friend may take it out.
- We get a Koton to take it out.
- His friend may take it out but only with a Shinui.
The object which is being transferred in our Mishnah is given into the עני's hand or the בעל הבית's hand. What issue does the Gemara have with this?
- Why is a poor man giving something to the rich man?
- Don't we need a 'מקום ד' על ד ?
- Don't we need a Karmelis?
- Why don't we קנס the עני ?
- Machlokes B&C.
One מזיד throws a ball מרשות היחיד לרשות היחיד ורשות הרבים באמצע on שבת he is ________ .
- חייב סקילה
- רבנן a חייב
- Sofek.
- Machlokes A&B.
זרק ונח ע"ג זיז כל שהוא assuming this is literal the Machlokes would be what?
- Did he do this מזיד ?
- Do we קנס the owner?
- Can he knock it of and be פטור ?
- Do we need a 'מקום ד' על ד or not?
- No Machlokes.
According to the Maskana we are talking about a tree which is standing in רה"י with its branches protruding into the רה"ר What is the Machlokes?
- Did he throw it high enough?
- Do the branches follow the tree?
- Is this a רבנן ?
- Machlokes A&B.
- Machlokes A&C.