Previous Daf

BAVA BASRA 65

Ask the Kollel

SUMMARY 1. Rav and Shmuel argue about whether the Halachah follows the opinion of Rebbi Akiva or of the Chachamim regarding the nature of a seller.   2. Even though Rav Huna was a disciple of Rav, he told Rav Nachman that the law follows Shmuel.   3. A house is generally sold without its movable parts.   4. Rebbi Meir argues that even the movable parts of a house are presumed to be included in the sale of the house.   5. The Gemara discusses the law of pipes that become attached to a Mikvah.

A BIT MORE 1. Rav: The law follows the Chachamim. Shmuel: The law follows Rebbi Akiva.   2. Rav Huna explained to Rav Nachman that the law follows "you and Shmuel (your Rebbi), as you are in a place where there are many judges." Rav Nachman therefore was able to learn how to judge accurately, and perhaps he even saw the many judges ruling in such a case).   3. However, if the seller says, "I am selling you the house and everything in it," he includes all of the movable parts in the sale.   4. Similarly, regarding a vineyard, Rebbi Meir says that all of the tools normally used for the vineyard are included in the sale.   5. If a pipe was made into a pipe before it was attached to a Mikvah, it can cause the Mikvah to become invalid, as the water running through it is deemed to be Mayim She'uvim, water drawn through a vessel (and such water invalidates a Mikvah). However, if a block of material was attached to a Mikvah and then made into a pipe, it is considered part of the ground, and water running through it does not invalidate a Mikvah.

Next Daf

MAIN BAVA BASRA PAGE

D.A.F. Home Page

---

Other Masechtos  •  Join Mailing Lists  •  Ask the Kollel Dafyomi Calendar  •  חומר בעברית Donations  •  Feedback  •  Dafyomi Links