ERUVIN 21-23, 25 - SPONSORED BY A GENEROUS GRANT FROM AN ANONYMOUS DONOR. KOLLEL IYUN HADAF IS INDEBTED TO HIM FOR HIS ENCOURAGEMENT AND SUPPORT AND PRAYS THAT HASH-M WILL REPAY HIM IN KIND.
קרפף יותר מבית סאתים שלא הוקף לדירה Sticking a board ten Tefachim high will work if it is how wide?
3 or under.
Between 3 and 4.
4 or over
Machlokes all the above.
Doesn't work.
קרפף יותר מבית סאתים שלא הוקף לדירה one plasters the walls thereby lessening the area. Does this help?
Yes.
No.
Only if the plaster can stand by itself.
Only if the plaster matches the wall. (we worry he might remove it.
Machlokes A&C.
If a Karfef was three Beis Sa'im, one Beis Se'ah of which was roofed, the roofed part is included when calculating the Karfef's area.
True.
True,but we don't carry there due to Maaris Ayin.
False.
Machlokes A&B.
Machlokes A&C.
One may carry in a normal (flat roofed) Achsadra in a valley.
True.
False.
Safek.
Machlokes A&B.
If a Karfef (Beis Sa'atayim) was totally breached to a Chatzer, it is forbidden to carry.
True, Chatzer space forbids.
True, it opens to a place into which it is forbidden to carry.
True, the breach space makes it bigger than Beis Sa'atayim.
Machlokes A&B.
C, Machlokes A&B.
There was an orchard [more than Beis Sa'atayim] outside a wall of a house which allowed carrrying in the orchard. This wall subsequently fell down do the interior house walls help?