More Discussions for this daf
1. Two days of Rosh Hashanah 2. Rosh Hashanah - 1 Day or 2 3. The Bais ha'Mikdash will...
4. Rosh Hashanah 5. Insights: Annuling an enactment of Beis Din 6. Akravas and Eilat
7. Mistake in Outlines 8. bi'Meshoch ha'Yovel 9. Niskalkelu ha'Leviyim b'Shir
10. Ha Lan Ha Lehu 11. When did the witnesses see the new moon 12. "Meherah Yibaneh"
13. Pushing off Rosh Chodesh 14. Two days of Rosh Hashanah, two Dinim 15. Egg laid on two days of ...
16. Saying the wrong Shir Shel Yom 17. Expiration of a Takanah 18. Covering an Egg
19. מהרה יבנה בית המקדש
DAF DISCUSSIONS - BEITZAH 5

Efraim Goldstein asked:

The gemarah in Beitza discusses the possibility of moving an egg in yom tov in order to make it safe. In addition, the reverse, moving a plate and using it to protect the egg, in effect just covering the egg with a protective covering, is also contemplated at length

in meseches eruvin and meseches shabbos when discussing the case of saving tefilin found in reshus harabim, there the gemarah also offers the possibility of covering the tefilin as a way to safeguard them.

I am puzzeled as to why in beitza the solution to cover is problematic and discussed at length while in eiruvin / shabbos the solution to cover is accepted without discussion. Both cases involve utilizing a non-mukktza item and covering a muktza (maybe) item with it.

Thank you for all your efforts

Efraim Goldstein, New York, USA

The Kollel replies:

It seems to me that the contemplation at length in Beitzah is more regarding the Sugya of Davar Sheyesh Lo Matirin. The main place where the topic of Muktzah is discussed regarding utilizing a non-Muktzah item to cover a Muktzah item is in Shabbos (43a), where Rebbi Yitzchak's statement that one may not do so (unless there is a case of Tzorech Mekomo) is discussed at length. [In any event, there are times when we say "Divrei Torah Aniyim b'Makom Echad v'Ashirim b'Makom Acher," -- "words of Torah are poor (not spoken about at length) in one place and rich in another place."]

Take Care,

Yaakov Montrose