More Discussions for this daf
1. Getting back change from Hekdesh 2. The Shevu'ah that the people make when the Shekalim are lost 3. Collateral (Mashkon)
4. Shekalim that were stolen or lost 5. Kalbon 6. Shemirah on Shekalim
7. דרכונות
DAF DISCUSSIONS - SHEKALIM 5

Mendy Y HIRTH asked:

(a) If the schleah was robbed or lost the money we collect it again.Say it

was $100 what will they do if only $50 are found do we collect quarters

from evryone (didnt give a machtzis)collect from half(which half?)collect

machtzis from all (put half in the wallpaper slot on purpose?)?

(b) We collect $100 a second time - is it a tashlumin for the first time or a new

chiyuv?Nafka minah if he became bar mitzva in between,before estate $ etc regarding

paying the kalbon?

(c) Does a person who missed giving give later ie he becomes bar mitva after

pesach?

(d)Does a person who dies after pesach also have the machtzis removed or

since it was already used (possibly) we dont remove it?

The Kollel replies:

(a) Divide the amount equally among all those who gave (as by Shutfus).

(b) A Tashlum. The Chiyuv is only before the first of Nissan.

(c) Same as above (b).

(d) No, it is removed only if he died before his money reached the Lishkah and before the Terumah (see Meiri).

Be well,

Mordecai Kornfeld

Mendy Y HIRTH comments:

With regard to question (a), in the interim I asked Rav Belsky. He said you cannot collect because hamotzi meychaveyro will come to play.