More Discussions for this daf
1. Times for the Bazichin and Tamid on Shabbos Erev Pesach 2. Halachic Time for the Afternoon Tamid 3. Korban Pesach Spoiling
4. Time of Musaf 5. First Mishna of Perek 6. סוגריים מרובעות ברש״י סוף העמוד
7. במכמר בשרא קמיפלגי
DAF DISCUSSIONS - PESACHIM 58

Meir Genut asks:

There is an argument whether the meat will spoil. Rabbi Akiva holds no at 7.5 hours and Rabbi Yishmael holds yes at 8.5. Karban Pesach is a Karban in Beis Hamikdash so why should it spoil as the Mishnah in Avot 5:8 teaches 10 miracles and one of them is meat not spoiling

The Mishnah

Meir Genut, Monsey, NY

The Kollel replies:

Dear Meir,

The Tzelach here (DH v'Omer) explains that on Daf 64b Rava and Abaye argue if Somchin Al haNes or not. Rava holds that we doen't rely on a miracle and must act accordingly, and therefore we do worry about spoilage. Abaye there holds that one can rely on the Nes, and therefore here he does not learn like Rava.

All the best,

Reuven Weiner