More Discussions for this daf
1. Answer to Review Question 7c 2. Kal va'Chomer - Yovel and Naarus - Dayo? 3. Cherem and Hekdesh
4. Can a Canaanite slave marry a Jewess? 5. כל חרם בישראל
DAF DISCUSSIONS - ERCHIN 29

Alexander Kutukov asks:

To the Collel's team sholom!

The question is as follows:

Is it right that there is no difference between heyrem and hekdesh? If it's right than in all the Shas we are to say that hekdesh hal al hekdesh at least in terms of hekdesh iluy - is it right? And if not why Rabbi Ishmoel learns the Halachos of heyrem from the psukim that speak strictly on hekdesh? (His daas in Mishno Arachin 29a concerns with heyrem for the reason that Rabbi Yehudo ben Bseyro is based on it).

Thank you and ksivo ve-chasomo toyvo!

Sincerely,

Alexander.

The Kollel replies:

I'm sure you are only asking according to the opinion of Rebbi Yehuda ben Beseirah, as opposed to (the major opinion of) the Chachamim who hold (28b) Stam Cherem l'Kohanim. The Rambam (Hilchos Erchin 6:1) indeed Paskens like the Chachamim. It is therefore difficult to assess the impact this has throughout Shas, especially regarding Hekdesh Iluy.

Take Care,

Yaakov Montrose