More Discussions for this daf
1. Arayos 2. MACHLOKES BET. R'YOCHANAN AND RISH LAKISH ON 14B 3. Question asked in the meat market
4. A person who is Tamei 5. Source of Reish Lakish for Achilas Terumah 6. v'El ha'Mikdash Lo Tavo
DAF DISCUSSIONS - MAKOS 14

ARI asked:

IN THE INYAN OF TAMEI SHACHAL KODESH- R YOCHANAN SAYS THAT HE USES THE POSUK OF BCHOL KODESH LO SIGA TO TEACH THTA IT IS ASUR TO TOUCH TRUMAH. WHEN RISH LAKISH SAYS THAT HE LEARNS THIS ISUR FROM THE POSUK OF ISH ISH MIZERAH AHARON... R' YOCHANAN SAYS THAT HE USES THAT POSUK TO TEACH THTA SOMEONE WHO IS TAMEI CANNOT EAT TRUMAH. THE QUESTION IS IF R' YOCHANAN LEARNS BCHOL KODESH LO SIGA TO TEACH THAT SOMEONE WHOIS TAMEI CANNOT TOUCH TRUMAH, WHY DOES HE NEED A SEPARATE POSUK TO TEACH THAT SOMEONE WHO IS TAMEI CANNOT EAT TRUMAH? EATING SHOULD BE INCLUSIVE IN TOUCHING.

PLEEASE LET ME KNOW.

ARI, NY,USA

The Kollel replies:

The Isur against touch Terumah while Tamei is not a Chiyuv Kares, while the Isur to eat it is a Chiyuv Kares.

D. Zupnik